In his introduction to Athanasius' On the Incarnation, C.S. Lewis encourages readers to read at least one old book for every three modern ones. This is good advice, both because (as Lewis points out) the old books are so accessible, and because modern books tend to be infinitely more complex and specialized than they have any need or right to be.
This is particularly true of Christian books (precisely the kinds of books Lewis is talking about, actually). As he says in the introduction, a Christian book must stand the test of time before it can be widely accepted, not because years equal truth, but because Christians must hold it against the Bible and the rest of accepted orthodox Christian doctrine.
One of the most important reasons to read old books in the Christian tradition, however, is that they are much clearer than most of the books published in the last two hundred years. The farther back we go, the clearer the writing: the Apostles' and Nicene Creeds are models of clarity and brevity, as well as some of the oldest Christian documents we have.
It's not just that the writing is clearer, but that the ideas expressed are so much simpler and Gospel-oriented. Modern writers fall over themselves responding to critics, clarifying their highly specialized use of language, cutting away the baggage of centuries of scholarship, or simply adding to it with their own assertions and ideas.
Of course, there's nonsense among the older works, too. Not everything the Church Fathers wrote is worthwhile, there's plenty of bad Medieval theology, the Renaissance and Enlightenment were largely too man-centered, and so on. But you're also far more likely to find excellent Christian writing in the literature of these periods than in our own era.
I would argue that it wasn't primarily because those writers were smarter, or better stylists, or anything temporal like that: they were simply more in love with Christ's true Gospel and its application to the life and thought of every believer. The Puritans in particular (here I'm betraying my own bias) are able to balance incredibly deep theological reflections and baldly practical applications of that knowledge.
We often somehow think that the more complex something is, the deeper it is; John Calvin and Martin Luther ably disprove this as a matter of course in their writings. Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion is one of the deepest doctrinal works you'll ever encounter, but on every page he shows how the concepts he explores are important for our life in Christ. The same goes for Luther's The Bondage of the Will and John Owen's The Death of Death in the Death of Christ.
Theological scholarship is important: it would be disingenuous of me to suggest otherwise. At the same time, it must always be balanced by serious reflection on the core doctrines of our faith: Christ's work, death, and resurrection; God's sovereignty; the universal curse of sin and death under Adam; the justification and sanctification of the saints through Christ; the life everlasting. Without an unbreakable anchor in these truths, the scholarship is meaningless and even harmful.
Even (especially?) popular works aren't free from the trend I've identified. While they aren't scholarly, authors of these books find anything to talk about but the Gospel, appealing to socio-economic analysis, social gospel concerns, psychology, postmodern ideas of "story," etc. to connect their message to a modern audience. The truths a modern audience needs to understand and affirm, however, are the same as they were 2000 years ago, and so is human nature.
We could read all the modern books, mindful to cut through the dross, looking for the kernel of truth or insight in each one; or we can read the old books, the ones focused on Christ alone, and be genuinely enriched and quickened to better service. The message hasn't changed, after all; we've simply invented more ways of getting around its incisive and convicting truth.
Wednesday, October 3, 2012
Tuesday, October 2, 2012
Ecclesiological Deism
The particular doctrinal mindset that allows Jack Crabtree to make his outrageous but not original claims is something I would call ecclesiological deism. It's a view I think he shares (to his chagrin, if he knew it) with many groups in contemporary Christendom. Basically, ecclesiological deism is the idea (implicit or explicit; both forms exist) that after Jesus instituted the Church, God stepped back and let His people sort things out for themselves.
Probably the most common source of this view is a misunderstanding of the apostolic age. If you think the Holy Spirit supply was simply cut off after the death of the last apostle, thus introducing an era of practical materialism, ED would make sense. Also, if our salvation depends primarily on knowledge, then it would make sense that we'd be fully responsible to apprehend it on our own through the exercise of our intellect and reason.
What any view leading to ED fails to acknowledge, however, is that the Church doesn't belong to Christians, but to Jesus Christ through the agency of the Holy Spirit for the Father's good pleasure and glory. The Church is not primarily a physical entity (though it has a physical element or manifestation), but a spiritual one. How else could Paul speak of it as the Body of Christ, the Bride of Christ, or the Temple of the Holy Spirit?
The implication for Jack's case is clear: if the Church is simply an invisible collective of people each striving for truth on their own recognizance, then of course he can reach the proper view of doctrine all by himself. If, however, the Church is the Body of Christ as maintained throughout the centuries by the Holy Spirit, his claims become a lot less plausible.
This isn't to say that no bad doctrine will ever creep into the Church. Because while the Holy Spirit is our guide and helper, we're also sinful human beings who don't always use our reason to the glory of God. It is to say that 2000 years of Christians haven't gotten the Gospel wrong. This isn't an intellectual cop-out: unless we think Christ abandoned His people to their own devices at the ascension, we have to understand that He left us with provisions against the complete loss of biblical truth in the form of His Spirit.
Perhaps Jack's ecclesiological deism results from his abandonment of the Trinity. People like Brian McLaren who hold similar (if not identical) beliefs seem to be influneced more by semi-Pelagian ideals and an overemphasis of common grace (both of which Jack seems to embrace as well). The temptation to elevate human beings beyond their due is a perennial problem, both within the Church and outside it. All we can do is renew our efforts to preserve the truth passed down to us from our spiritual forebears under the auspices of God's Holy Spirit.
Probably the most common source of this view is a misunderstanding of the apostolic age. If you think the Holy Spirit supply was simply cut off after the death of the last apostle, thus introducing an era of practical materialism, ED would make sense. Also, if our salvation depends primarily on knowledge, then it would make sense that we'd be fully responsible to apprehend it on our own through the exercise of our intellect and reason.
What any view leading to ED fails to acknowledge, however, is that the Church doesn't belong to Christians, but to Jesus Christ through the agency of the Holy Spirit for the Father's good pleasure and glory. The Church is not primarily a physical entity (though it has a physical element or manifestation), but a spiritual one. How else could Paul speak of it as the Body of Christ, the Bride of Christ, or the Temple of the Holy Spirit?
The implication for Jack's case is clear: if the Church is simply an invisible collective of people each striving for truth on their own recognizance, then of course he can reach the proper view of doctrine all by himself. If, however, the Church is the Body of Christ as maintained throughout the centuries by the Holy Spirit, his claims become a lot less plausible.
This isn't to say that no bad doctrine will ever creep into the Church. Because while the Holy Spirit is our guide and helper, we're also sinful human beings who don't always use our reason to the glory of God. It is to say that 2000 years of Christians haven't gotten the Gospel wrong. This isn't an intellectual cop-out: unless we think Christ abandoned His people to their own devices at the ascension, we have to understand that He left us with provisions against the complete loss of biblical truth in the form of His Spirit.
Perhaps Jack's ecclesiological deism results from his abandonment of the Trinity. People like Brian McLaren who hold similar (if not identical) beliefs seem to be influneced more by semi-Pelagian ideals and an overemphasis of common grace (both of which Jack seems to embrace as well). The temptation to elevate human beings beyond their due is a perennial problem, both within the Church and outside it. All we can do is renew our efforts to preserve the truth passed down to us from our spiritual forebears under the auspices of God's Holy Spirit.
Monday, October 1, 2012
Ancient Modernism and Intellectual Individualism
I've been preoccupied with heresy lately because a man I'd consider one of my intellectual mentors recently revealed himself to be a thorough heretic. Less than a year ago, Jack Crabtree of Gutenberg College in Eugene, OR issued a series of lectures at his church (Reformation Fellowship) condemning most of the core orthodox teachings of Christianity and putting in their place a variety of resuscitated heresies.
When I was a teenager, I attended a philosophy discussion group led by Jack and his brother David, in which we read texts and talked about them. I'm guessing we were exposed to some weird ideas (in retrospect), but the value was that we learned how to analyze texts and form ideas, how to interact with the ideas of others, and how to think logically. I'd give my dad most of the credit for my ability to do those things, but many of the skills he'd taught me were focused and honed in the discussion group, and I was forced to defend my statements by people who often didn't agree with me.
In light of this new development, I can see that one of Jack's purposes for the group was to impart a Greek sense of intellectual individualism to each of us, to force us to wrestle with every idea we held and to reconcile them all into a workable whole. On one hand this is an ability every Christian needs to foster: there's too much shoddy thinking, lack of thinking, and pernicious thinking in the Church, and we need to counter it with good theology, good philosophy, and good logic.
At the same time, we need to fit our thinking in to the broader picture already assembled by those Christians who've gone before us. I'm not suggesting we ought to blindly accept everything handed to us by our pastors and elders, by Christian thinkers, even by the Church fathers. No one is infallible, and everyone makes errors. Scripture is our final standard for truth, and it is that rather than human dogmatism to which we submit.
I am suggesting that human fallibility spreads beyond the Church fathers or contemporary pastors and includes every one of us, no matter how intellectually astute we find ourselves to be. We cannot hope to assemble a coherent theory of everything independent of everyone else, not only because we're fallible, but because we're finite, limited, and chronically subjective even when we believe ourselves to be wholly objective. The second someone says they've finally figured everything out, I immediately become suspicious of everything they say subsequently.
Which is how Jack Crabtree began his lectures (available here), positing that he was sitting in a coffee shop when suddenly the whole "Christianity thing" made sense to him. Unfortunately, his "Christianity thing" excludes a meaningful doctrine of the atonement and justification, calls our sin nature "a philosophical fiction" and claims "it doesn't exist," eliminates the beautiful doctrine of the Trinity, and imparts to Jesus mere God-consciousness rather than actual deity. All this is the result, not of humble submission to Church doctrine tempered with arduous and careful study, but of a desire to simply "make sense" of the Bible in purely rationalist terms.
There are plenty who would simply retreat from this extreme individualism into a dogmatism that is deaf, blind, and speechless. As a Reformed and Presbyterian Christian I acknowledge and even celebrate a certain kind of dogmatism, but only a dogmatism that is informed and able to interact with traditions outside itself. The insular dogmatism is certainly not the right response to Jack's radical individualism, mainly because it provides no basis for showing him his error.
The proper response, what I would call the ancient modern solution to this problem, is to admit the necessity of personal study while submitting to the standards for doctrinal orthodoxy handed down through all true Christian traditions. To presume that the entire Church has been wrong for two thousand years, and that one man can finally discover the truth found in Scripture all by himself in the 21st century, simply doesn't make sense. He claims we've been bullied and forced to believe the doctrine of the Trinity, but I challenge you to show me one person who believes in the Trinity who doesn't do so of their own accord.
Do any of us fully understand the doctrine of the Trinity? No, absolutely not. Does that mean it isn't a true doctrine? Only if human reason is the final standard for truth. But if you understand God to be an infinite transcendent being, whose self-revelation in the Bible includes both paradox and mystery, it only makes sense that there would be essential truths about his nature and character that would be impossible for fallen, finite, subjective human beings to grasp entirely. Jack's real sin, therefore, isn't his accusation against the Church, it's his presumption that he can know and understand everything the Bible proclaims about Yahweh, and that he can do so entirely on his own.
When I was a teenager, I attended a philosophy discussion group led by Jack and his brother David, in which we read texts and talked about them. I'm guessing we were exposed to some weird ideas (in retrospect), but the value was that we learned how to analyze texts and form ideas, how to interact with the ideas of others, and how to think logically. I'd give my dad most of the credit for my ability to do those things, but many of the skills he'd taught me were focused and honed in the discussion group, and I was forced to defend my statements by people who often didn't agree with me.
In light of this new development, I can see that one of Jack's purposes for the group was to impart a Greek sense of intellectual individualism to each of us, to force us to wrestle with every idea we held and to reconcile them all into a workable whole. On one hand this is an ability every Christian needs to foster: there's too much shoddy thinking, lack of thinking, and pernicious thinking in the Church, and we need to counter it with good theology, good philosophy, and good logic.
At the same time, we need to fit our thinking in to the broader picture already assembled by those Christians who've gone before us. I'm not suggesting we ought to blindly accept everything handed to us by our pastors and elders, by Christian thinkers, even by the Church fathers. No one is infallible, and everyone makes errors. Scripture is our final standard for truth, and it is that rather than human dogmatism to which we submit.
I am suggesting that human fallibility spreads beyond the Church fathers or contemporary pastors and includes every one of us, no matter how intellectually astute we find ourselves to be. We cannot hope to assemble a coherent theory of everything independent of everyone else, not only because we're fallible, but because we're finite, limited, and chronically subjective even when we believe ourselves to be wholly objective. The second someone says they've finally figured everything out, I immediately become suspicious of everything they say subsequently.
Which is how Jack Crabtree began his lectures (available here), positing that he was sitting in a coffee shop when suddenly the whole "Christianity thing" made sense to him. Unfortunately, his "Christianity thing" excludes a meaningful doctrine of the atonement and justification, calls our sin nature "a philosophical fiction" and claims "it doesn't exist," eliminates the beautiful doctrine of the Trinity, and imparts to Jesus mere God-consciousness rather than actual deity. All this is the result, not of humble submission to Church doctrine tempered with arduous and careful study, but of a desire to simply "make sense" of the Bible in purely rationalist terms.
There are plenty who would simply retreat from this extreme individualism into a dogmatism that is deaf, blind, and speechless. As a Reformed and Presbyterian Christian I acknowledge and even celebrate a certain kind of dogmatism, but only a dogmatism that is informed and able to interact with traditions outside itself. The insular dogmatism is certainly not the right response to Jack's radical individualism, mainly because it provides no basis for showing him his error.
The proper response, what I would call the ancient modern solution to this problem, is to admit the necessity of personal study while submitting to the standards for doctrinal orthodoxy handed down through all true Christian traditions. To presume that the entire Church has been wrong for two thousand years, and that one man can finally discover the truth found in Scripture all by himself in the 21st century, simply doesn't make sense. He claims we've been bullied and forced to believe the doctrine of the Trinity, but I challenge you to show me one person who believes in the Trinity who doesn't do so of their own accord.
Do any of us fully understand the doctrine of the Trinity? No, absolutely not. Does that mean it isn't a true doctrine? Only if human reason is the final standard for truth. But if you understand God to be an infinite transcendent being, whose self-revelation in the Bible includes both paradox and mystery, it only makes sense that there would be essential truths about his nature and character that would be impossible for fallen, finite, subjective human beings to grasp entirely. Jack's real sin, therefore, isn't his accusation against the Church, it's his presumption that he can know and understand everything the Bible proclaims about Yahweh, and that he can do so entirely on his own.
Saturday, September 29, 2012
A few good reasons to not like Hollywood.
- Johnny Depp is celebrated as a great actor, apparently in virtue of his ability to look perpetually surprised at his own drunkenness.
- Mel Bay.
- Jurassic Park came out when you were young enough that you still remember it with nostalgic fondness.
- Tim Burton.
- Slow motion and 3-D.
- Every musical score is the product of equal parts Howard Shore, John Williams, and unbridled maudlin sentimentality.
- Films in which Shia LaBeouf manages to stutter and look confused become massive box-office successes; films in which he proves his acting abilities remain largely unknown.
- Films which are remakes of themselves (Johnny Mnemonic/The Matrix) don't even have the decency to cast a human being in the lead role. Granted, both films feature Keanu Reaves playing himself as a computer, but at least 2001 featured a computer who could act.
- Russell Crowe actually seems like a really good actor compared to most of his colleagues.
- Steven Spielberg is allowed to make historical dramas.
- Steven Spielberg is allowed to make films.
- Steven Spielberg.
- The Academy Awards.
- Books that are shorter than War and Peace are allowed to be made into more than one film.
- CGI.
- Tom Cruise.
- The original version of Sleuth is out of print; Saving Private Ryan exists in a collector's edition.
Friday, September 28, 2012
The proud and the humble.
We need to be careful at the outset not to let our humility become our arrogance, and to let ourselves diminish for the sake of the Gospel. The problem with all heresies is that they're always predicated on hubris—the heretic believes he sees the truth of Scripture more clearly than all the saints who have come before, and that his own reason is superior to their collected reason.
This doesn't mean we affirm truth by consensus or anything of the sort. The logical reaction to "one finite man can't apprehend all truth by himself" is not "truth is that which has been agreed upon by the majority." What we need to affirm, instead, is that God has given us as much truth as we can handle in His Word, that He intends His whole Church to apprehend that Church as a body rather than as individuals, and that the truth present in the Bible is bigger than any one or group of us.
By bigger I don't mean to suggest that it is therefore immaterial or shouldn't be sought after, but that the Bible, for all its clarity, is also incredibly abstruse at times and presents problems that aren't easily dismissed. How could it be otherwise? Christians take the Bible to be the self-revelation of a transcendent God communicating Himself both narratively and propositionally to finite human beings who are necessarily limited.
No heretic takes any of that seriously. That doesn't mean he can't make a seemingly airtight case for his position, or that he can't root that position in his own interpretation of Scripture; it simply means that he doesn't think his intellect is limited, and that he can figure everything out if he just thinks about it hard enough. In essence, then, he sets himself in a position of equality with the King of Heaven and Lord of the Universe.
Heretics often make their ideas seem humble. They couch them in peculiarly imminent terms, often gentle terms, trying to give us a sense of their Christian virtue and willingness to submit to Truth rather than to mere Tradition. What they fail to acknowledge is that their whole project is inherently arrogant, and abbrogates one of the key tenets of the Christian faith: the emphasis on unity.
An appeal to tradition is likely to spark controversy of its own in many quarters. What I mean is not tradition in the Roman Catholic sense, in which extrabiblical doctrine and practice is imported in virtue of its use within the Church. Tradition in the Reformed sense refers to no more than the essential teachings of the Church as maintained by faithful Christians through the power of the Holy Spirit acting on reason and practice. The clearest and most basic expression of these teachings can be found in the ecumenical creeds, and in the three forms of unity and the Westminster standards.
Submitting to these doctrines requires humility. Do the creeds and confessions contain doctrines that are difficult to understand and grasp? Absolutely, but so too does the Bible. Assuming that we can make perfect sense of God Himself is beyond courage: it's outright rebellion and unmitigated pride posing as intellectual freedom. To those who would reject the creeds I can only ask what alternative there is; how can we be sure we've got it right if we jettison the teachings of all those who came before us in the name of Jesus?
Humility requires our admission (primarily to ourselves) that we can't know everything, especially everything about God, and that we can't know anything perfectly or fully. Jesus didn't call a bunch of individuals to individually be His Church; He calls individuals to become united in Him as His Church, submitting to Himself and to one another in love. This doesn't appeal to human pride, but it is the only way we can hope to be united to Christ, or to understand the truth of His incomprehensibly gracious and beautiful Gospel.
This doesn't mean we affirm truth by consensus or anything of the sort. The logical reaction to "one finite man can't apprehend all truth by himself" is not "truth is that which has been agreed upon by the majority." What we need to affirm, instead, is that God has given us as much truth as we can handle in His Word, that He intends His whole Church to apprehend that Church as a body rather than as individuals, and that the truth present in the Bible is bigger than any one or group of us.
By bigger I don't mean to suggest that it is therefore immaterial or shouldn't be sought after, but that the Bible, for all its clarity, is also incredibly abstruse at times and presents problems that aren't easily dismissed. How could it be otherwise? Christians take the Bible to be the self-revelation of a transcendent God communicating Himself both narratively and propositionally to finite human beings who are necessarily limited.
No heretic takes any of that seriously. That doesn't mean he can't make a seemingly airtight case for his position, or that he can't root that position in his own interpretation of Scripture; it simply means that he doesn't think his intellect is limited, and that he can figure everything out if he just thinks about it hard enough. In essence, then, he sets himself in a position of equality with the King of Heaven and Lord of the Universe.
Heretics often make their ideas seem humble. They couch them in peculiarly imminent terms, often gentle terms, trying to give us a sense of their Christian virtue and willingness to submit to Truth rather than to mere Tradition. What they fail to acknowledge is that their whole project is inherently arrogant, and abbrogates one of the key tenets of the Christian faith: the emphasis on unity.
An appeal to tradition is likely to spark controversy of its own in many quarters. What I mean is not tradition in the Roman Catholic sense, in which extrabiblical doctrine and practice is imported in virtue of its use within the Church. Tradition in the Reformed sense refers to no more than the essential teachings of the Church as maintained by faithful Christians through the power of the Holy Spirit acting on reason and practice. The clearest and most basic expression of these teachings can be found in the ecumenical creeds, and in the three forms of unity and the Westminster standards.
Submitting to these doctrines requires humility. Do the creeds and confessions contain doctrines that are difficult to understand and grasp? Absolutely, but so too does the Bible. Assuming that we can make perfect sense of God Himself is beyond courage: it's outright rebellion and unmitigated pride posing as intellectual freedom. To those who would reject the creeds I can only ask what alternative there is; how can we be sure we've got it right if we jettison the teachings of all those who came before us in the name of Jesus?
Humility requires our admission (primarily to ourselves) that we can't know everything, especially everything about God, and that we can't know anything perfectly or fully. Jesus didn't call a bunch of individuals to individually be His Church; He calls individuals to become united in Him as His Church, submitting to Himself and to one another in love. This doesn't appeal to human pride, but it is the only way we can hope to be united to Christ, or to understand the truth of His incomprehensibly gracious and beautiful Gospel.
Thursday, September 27, 2012
God, the maker of analogies
Another thing heretics often do is to try to establish a single metaphor for God and His workings in and through the world. One of the men I mentioned in the last post has attempted to make his new theology coherent by using a "God-as-author" analogy in which God's sovereignty is explained by comparing Him to a novelist and we humans to the characters in the novel.
There's nothing immediately wrong with the analogy. In some ways, in fact, it's very helpful: we often trip up on the doctrines of God's election, foreknowledge, and foreordination, and imagining Him to be writing us can be useful in explaining those things. It's when the analogy doesn't stop where it should that the whole thing goes wrong.
Christ's deity, for instance, is whittled down to fit into the overriding metaphor. Christ is no longer the eternally-existing second person of the Trinity, He's simply a human God used to put Himself into the story He was writing. Christ, then, is as created and ontologically one-sided as we are, except that Yahweh put Himself into the consciousness of Jesus so He could interact with us.
Too many things are wrong with that to address them all here. The point is, if the individual in question were willing to relinquish his analogy when biblical doctrine has clearly outgrown or transcended it, he wouldn't be in the position he is of rejecting centuries of received Christian doctrine. Of course, he doesn't care that he's done this, but we should.
We should also try to learn something about the use of analogies in the Bible itself. God never uses a single metaphor to explain Himself, His operations, or His will for mankind simply because a single metaphor isn't sufficient. God created metaphor, and He created the analagous objects and ideas which serve every metaphor; how could just one ever tell us everything we need to know about Him?
If our goal really is to get at the root of the Bible's message, it seems to me that our first task should be to understand what kind of book the Bible is. It isn't simply a collection of literary pieces, and it isn't only a series of rational/intellectual propositional statements. Why? Because God can't be reduced to a single theme, idea, or rational precept.
The problem with heresies is that they never give God His due, they never allow the God of the universe to transcend or overwhelm or baffle His creation, they never suffice. We should be afraid of worshipping a God who stays strictly within humanly comprehensible lines; we should be terrified not to worship the God of all things who routinely challenges our perceptions and our clockwork reductionism.
There's nothing immediately wrong with the analogy. In some ways, in fact, it's very helpful: we often trip up on the doctrines of God's election, foreknowledge, and foreordination, and imagining Him to be writing us can be useful in explaining those things. It's when the analogy doesn't stop where it should that the whole thing goes wrong.
Christ's deity, for instance, is whittled down to fit into the overriding metaphor. Christ is no longer the eternally-existing second person of the Trinity, He's simply a human God used to put Himself into the story He was writing. Christ, then, is as created and ontologically one-sided as we are, except that Yahweh put Himself into the consciousness of Jesus so He could interact with us.
Too many things are wrong with that to address them all here. The point is, if the individual in question were willing to relinquish his analogy when biblical doctrine has clearly outgrown or transcended it, he wouldn't be in the position he is of rejecting centuries of received Christian doctrine. Of course, he doesn't care that he's done this, but we should.
We should also try to learn something about the use of analogies in the Bible itself. God never uses a single metaphor to explain Himself, His operations, or His will for mankind simply because a single metaphor isn't sufficient. God created metaphor, and He created the analagous objects and ideas which serve every metaphor; how could just one ever tell us everything we need to know about Him?
If our goal really is to get at the root of the Bible's message, it seems to me that our first task should be to understand what kind of book the Bible is. It isn't simply a collection of literary pieces, and it isn't only a series of rational/intellectual propositional statements. Why? Because God can't be reduced to a single theme, idea, or rational precept.
The problem with heresies is that they never give God His due, they never allow the God of the universe to transcend or overwhelm or baffle His creation, they never suffice. We should be afraid of worshipping a God who stays strictly within humanly comprehensible lines; we should be terrified not to worship the God of all things who routinely challenges our perceptions and our clockwork reductionism.
Wednesday, September 26, 2012
The Danger of Heresy
Sometimes heretics (especially those emerging from orthodox quarters of Christianity) misrepresent the Christian attitude toward heresy. This should surprise no one, but it does call for clarification and rebuttal. A couple men I'd consider mentors in the early stages of my intellectual pilgrimage have recently revealed themselves as heretics (forthrightly, as it happens), and have made the same mistake many others have made in trying to guess why Christians eschew their teaching.
The misrpesentation is this: Christians are characterized as believing it is doctrinal knowledge alone that leads to salvation, that without doctrinal knowledge an individual is eternally damned, and that lack of such knowledge makes one an enemy and an outsider. The difficulty, I believe, is that heresy is always a lack of, or distortion of, orthodox Christian propositions, and therefore its formulators see everything in terms of the intellect.
Orthodox Christian doctrine is often hard to swallow, even for the most devout. How can Jesus have two natures? How can God be three persons yet indivisible? How can man be responsible for his actions even while his every action is foreordained by God? In what way precisely does the atonement take away our sins? These are all difficult questions (difficult is really too soft a word), and no one has ever answered them adequately.
The reason for this should be obvious to anyone. These doctrines are truths about an infinite, transcendent God, recorded for us asystematically in a book that defies genre and categorization in any meaningful sense except as the Word of that same transcendent God. That Scripture is God's own self-revelation is the only reason we are able to understand anything about Him; even so, we are finite and sinful human beings, and the only resolution we can offer for many of the doctrines we find between Genesis and Revelation is to plead for mystery.
If the Bible states two things that seem to be in opposition (God is three persons yet one God, for instance), we accept both of these concepts as truth and assume that they are deeper and more glorious than we can comprehend. As Christians, our immediate response should not be to dismiss one or the other (or both) of these concepts, but to plead ignorance as to their fulness. Any other response is blasphemous in its arrogance and pride.
Heretics assume that, when they encounter a doctrine they don't understand, it is the doctrine rather than the reader that must yield. Human reason, for them, can be bound by nothing, least of all by propositional concepts. So, they attempt to make sense of every part of Scripture, using as guide only their reason and casting aside all reliance on past saints, the wisdom of the ancients, or the received/traditional/orthodox interpretations.
This is because heretics misunderstand true spirituality and the necessity of pure doctrine. Good doctrine isn't so essential simply because it's knowledge; it's essential because it helps us identify the God we serve and worship. Likewise, true spirituality isn't a purely rational or intellectual matter; it's the transformation of the heart, soul, mind and body through the healing agency of the Triune God, the reclamation of what was lost to salvation and goodness.
It's ironic that heretics so often blame the orthodox for overemphasizing knowledge when that's exactly what they're doing. It's also strange that anyone could think the Holy Spirit would have so abandoned His people as to allow them to wallow for two millennia in false doctrine, and that one or two people would be the lone voices in the wilderness proferring the truth. Such ideas are sad in their arrogance and ludicrous in their absurdity.
Does the Bible ever use the word Trinity? Of course not, and no true Christian supposes it does, or that the doctrine is laid out anywhere in anything close to a systematic form. But the Bible does present an organic picture of God that reveals insofar as we can understand who He is, who we are, and what our relationship with Him is and should be. Why does the Bible go on to reveal paradoxes concerning Him? Because He is the transcendent God, and we aren't meant to understand everything about Him, nor would we survive the ordeal were such knowledge given to us mere mortals.
The misrpesentation is this: Christians are characterized as believing it is doctrinal knowledge alone that leads to salvation, that without doctrinal knowledge an individual is eternally damned, and that lack of such knowledge makes one an enemy and an outsider. The difficulty, I believe, is that heresy is always a lack of, or distortion of, orthodox Christian propositions, and therefore its formulators see everything in terms of the intellect.
Orthodox Christian doctrine is often hard to swallow, even for the most devout. How can Jesus have two natures? How can God be three persons yet indivisible? How can man be responsible for his actions even while his every action is foreordained by God? In what way precisely does the atonement take away our sins? These are all difficult questions (difficult is really too soft a word), and no one has ever answered them adequately.
The reason for this should be obvious to anyone. These doctrines are truths about an infinite, transcendent God, recorded for us asystematically in a book that defies genre and categorization in any meaningful sense except as the Word of that same transcendent God. That Scripture is God's own self-revelation is the only reason we are able to understand anything about Him; even so, we are finite and sinful human beings, and the only resolution we can offer for many of the doctrines we find between Genesis and Revelation is to plead for mystery.
If the Bible states two things that seem to be in opposition (God is three persons yet one God, for instance), we accept both of these concepts as truth and assume that they are deeper and more glorious than we can comprehend. As Christians, our immediate response should not be to dismiss one or the other (or both) of these concepts, but to plead ignorance as to their fulness. Any other response is blasphemous in its arrogance and pride.
Heretics assume that, when they encounter a doctrine they don't understand, it is the doctrine rather than the reader that must yield. Human reason, for them, can be bound by nothing, least of all by propositional concepts. So, they attempt to make sense of every part of Scripture, using as guide only their reason and casting aside all reliance on past saints, the wisdom of the ancients, or the received/traditional/orthodox interpretations.
This is because heretics misunderstand true spirituality and the necessity of pure doctrine. Good doctrine isn't so essential simply because it's knowledge; it's essential because it helps us identify the God we serve and worship. Likewise, true spirituality isn't a purely rational or intellectual matter; it's the transformation of the heart, soul, mind and body through the healing agency of the Triune God, the reclamation of what was lost to salvation and goodness.
It's ironic that heretics so often blame the orthodox for overemphasizing knowledge when that's exactly what they're doing. It's also strange that anyone could think the Holy Spirit would have so abandoned His people as to allow them to wallow for two millennia in false doctrine, and that one or two people would be the lone voices in the wilderness proferring the truth. Such ideas are sad in their arrogance and ludicrous in their absurdity.
Does the Bible ever use the word Trinity? Of course not, and no true Christian supposes it does, or that the doctrine is laid out anywhere in anything close to a systematic form. But the Bible does present an organic picture of God that reveals insofar as we can understand who He is, who we are, and what our relationship with Him is and should be. Why does the Bible go on to reveal paradoxes concerning Him? Because He is the transcendent God, and we aren't meant to understand everything about Him, nor would we survive the ordeal were such knowledge given to us mere mortals.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)