Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Love and Fear

There were hundreds, thousands of birds. There were so many birds I was still seeing them after they were long past, moving specks entwined in the soft orange of the sun blending with the horizon. They were swallows, brown and not still and crowded in the air, but I thought they might be doves come to warn us of God's love.

All men tremble at God's wrath; how many weep and shake in the shadow of His love? How many see those gentle birds as harbingers of peace, rather than harpies from the throne of the Most High sent to terrify us into His presence? Why is love now all gentle smiles and kindness? What about the kindness of fire and whirlwind?

Where I live it's rare to see more than a moderate flock of birds at one time. Traffic on the freeway slowed in the midst of silent wings, each of us awed by the sheer number. Number itself is frightening to those who are singularities. We are one; in the face of multiplicity we tremble, afraid of being overwhelmed. This is partly why we fear God.

God is perfect singularity because He is also perfect multiplicity. We fear Christ because He is both God and man, a lion and the lamb, two natures in one person. When one thing reveals itself to be more than itself, our human propensity is to hide, to shut ourselves away from what is capable of overwhelming us. So it is with the peace and love of God.

The love of God that set the Son at the Father's right hand is the same love that will judge all men from the throne of justice. The peace that surpasses all understanding issues from the same source as the wrath that plagued Egypt tenfold. Moses strikes a rock and lives; he strikes another, and dies. For all that we can know about God from His Word, He remains a mystery, transcendent.

We embrace the softness of swallows, the hazed blur at the edges of wings as they flail in the sunset, clouds that have deigned to come near the earth. We listen to their high voices like the voices of careless angels, sharp and clear and sudden. We smile as they play, smile as they jerk their little heads back and forth, smile as Adam must have smiled naming them.

But when they swirl like an Israelite smoke column, cutting us off from the sky, hemming us to the dust from which God stirred us, then we wish them dispersed. Then their song becomes a banshee shriek, a siren of impending doom, the storm that is God's love. All the swallows but one flock, and we are afraid because the many are one.

It is good to fear God, as much because He is love as because He is all perfection and strength. How can we exult in the selfless love of Christ without hiding our faces from its ultimate expression on the stark and lonely cross? How can we love His creation without dreading its terrors? How can we love the little swallow and not shake when he becomes a host?

Monday, September 24, 2012

The Importance of Reading Books

A lot of people talk about how important it is to read books but seldom provide compelling reasons. It isn't enough to encourage reading for its own sake—that's just begging the question. It's not even enough to encourage reading certain kinds of books for their own sake—that's just posturing. When anyone tells me to read the Classics, for instance, simply because they're the Classics, I immediately want to know why they're the Classics, who gave them that distinction, what a Classic even is, and why reading one is inherently beneficial.

Others give one-dimensional answers when asked why reading is important. The purpose of reading, they may say, is to gain knowledge, or to "broaden oneself," or to understand, or some other not necessarily bad but far from complete answer. Of these apologists I want to ask, why is knowledge important? won't experience broaden me? can't I understand without books?

The immediate reply to the second question will likely be, "But you can't have as many experiences in real life as you can in books." So reading is simply an existential exercise? We read only to dip our feet in a wider pool of experience than would otherwise be open to us? If that's the case, why not simply watch a bunch of movies? It generally takes less time to watch a film than to read a book, so if we just watch plenty of movies we'll be all right. Oh, the reply comes, reading is so much better than just watching movies. But why?

Such questioning is likely only to produce frustration, however. For many defenders of reading, their arguments are couched solely in terms of preference: these individuals like to read, and so they try to construct paradigms in which reading is preferable to not reading. None of these paradigms are very realistic, however, and usually they're simply another ruse for separating the goats and the sheep. Am I saying that reading, then, is merely a game, unimportant, and worthless?

I am saying no such thing. Reading books (the right ones, anyway; there's plenty of garbage out there) is extremely important, and I'll be the first to defend the practice. But anything worth doing is worth defending properly, and the more important an activity is, the more important it becomes to defend it well and responsibly. Simply saying "read cause it's good" or "read these books cause they're these books" is juvenile and actually a pretty good reason not to read whatever is being presented as worthy literature.

While vicarious experience has a modicum of value (not near as much as is often assumed), and knowledge can be a good thing (a wonderful thing, even; and also, a terrible and horrible thing), these are not in themselves sufficient reasons to read books. The real reason to read is for perspective. It's awfully easy to assume humankind has progressed imeasurably, or philosophical questions are different today than those posed by Socrates and Aristotle, or that Americans know what's going on better than anyone, or that Europeans are inherently more sophisticated than everyone else, or whatever. The only real way to understand these are all lies is to read authors who identify them as such.

Sure, going to Europe will probably clue you in to the fact that rednecks, hipsters, and drug addicts exist everywhere, but then again, you might be so overawed by the exotic unfamiliarity of it all that you come back with a universally positive report. Sitting in your chair at home and reading about another culture from a fairly objective point of view will likely yield much more balanced results, though. And while it's entirely possible that your chosen author will have rose-colored glasses of her own, or will be a curmudgeon with nothing nice to say, that will (to an observant reader) become clear as the book progresses.

Which is the reason to read widely. It's not going to do any good to read for perspective if you only read one or two authors, or only read three books a year, or only read escapist literature, or only read fiction. These habits will simply succeed in foisting narrow perspectives, and will probably end up worse in the long run than if you read nothing at all. Reading for improvement or benefit is pretty much either a commitment or nothing; you can't do it halfway.

Perspective is largely why we read the Bible. It shows us who we are, who God's people are, what the world is like, why it is like that, and (supremely and all-importantly) it shows us who God is. We don't read Scripture simply for the stories (or, as pomos would stress, the story), for knowledge, or for fun. We read God's Word for the perspective no other book can offer, and this is why we ought to read it more often than any other book. At the same time, good books can help flesh out this perspective, or enhance our biblical perspective, and this is why we read those other books, too.

Friday, September 21, 2012

MGT and other things I've never heard of.

I recently read a book by Calvin Beisner called Evangelical Heathenism?: Examining Contemporary Revivalism. In it, he reveals a contemporary heresy known as Moral Government Theology, which is basically a form of Pelagianism and open theism. Apparently many leaders of Youth With a Mission have been or are mixed up in this doctrinal error (heresy, blasphemy, etc.), actively teaching that humans are born with the internal ability to choose good or bad, that God doesn't know the future, and that God's goodness hinges on His constant choices rather than His inherent nature.

Needless to say, there's a lot wrong with this idea. What really disturbed me, however, is that such an idea exists and is largely unheard of. The fact that almost no one has heard about MGT while at the same time it is so pernicious and apparently widespread bodes ill for the watchfulness Christians are supposed to maintain in the face of doctrinal error.

How many Christians have been unwittingly drawn into this way of thinking? It would seem that a doctrine teaching a god who is neither omniscient nor omnipotent would be automatically rejected by Christians across the board, but that is apparently not the case. Obviously, there are many firm enough in orthodox doctrine that they can't or won't be dissuaded from the truth, but what makes these doctrines appealing to less well-educated Christians?

There seem to be only two factors, both working in tandem. First, the idea that we are completely autonomous free moral agents who can thwart the will of God plays on our inherited human pride and arrogance. This is likely a subconscious motivating factor, but one nonetheless that is powerful and omnipresent in all of us: every time we sin, we're asserting our own godhood.

The second factor is lack of knowledge and rejection of any kind of authority. Our churches are notoriously lax in doctrinal instruction, opting for feel-good sermons and opinion-based Bible studies rather than rigorous doctrinal catechesis and exhortation. But it's more than that: contemporary Christians are completely uncomfortable with the notion of objective absolute truth, and with the idea that humans can obtain it.

Oddly, this seems most rampant in what most would classify as conservative Evangelical churches, concentrations of Fundamentalism in its most restricted and unbiblical sense. On one hand, they cry out that there is truth and meaning, but through their behavior and teaching they deny it. How is this best demonstrated? Through the near-universal rejection of the creeds and confessions of the historic Body of Christ.

But, they argue, the Bible is our final authority! As interpreted by whom? we may well ask, to which the response is usually silence or an appeal to the Holy Spirit. Yet, if the Church is truly a body, wouldn't the Holy Spirit reveal Scriptural truth to the group as a whole, rather than to each person individually? Can we not trust anyone but ourselves? Such spiritual solipsism is not only dangerous, it's rank unbiblicism.

By it, heresies like MGT are allowed entry under the guise of proper interpretation and piety. Ultimately, if there is no objective interpretive method external to the individual, there is no interpretive method, and therefore no grounds for dismissing heresy. If, on the other hand, the Holy Spirit has revealed truth to the Church as a whole to be safeguarded by all true believers, then we have guidelines for objectively determining what is right and what is wrong, for dismissing heresy, and for training the saints in doctrine. If we let this go, we've relinquished our faith entirely, and only destruction will ensue. The only proper response is faithful doctrine and faithful living in the face of opposition from without as well as from within.

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Chaos and Light

If it is true of moths and flames, it's much truer of humans and chaos. Where darkness gathers, people throng; where it is light they disperse and flee. Shame and guilt, carried by each of us, prefers to hide rather than to be made known, but there's more to it than that.

Finite humans constantly struggle against confusion. There's too much to make sense of, so to remain sane we hide in oblivion, erasing the boundaries to make room for paradox. Somehow we convince ourselves that the void of chaos is more interesting, more liberating, and more all-encompassing than the colors and definition of broad daylight. Somehow we believe what we can't see is deeper than what we are able to behold. Somehow, we believe chaos is more mysterious than order.

Whatever else John Hillcoat may believe, at leat he understands that such a proposition is absurd, that the light will always be more fascinating than the darkness, and that the complexity of good is sufficient to render evil meaningless. His two most recent films, The Road (2009) and Lawless (2012), ably demonstrate this.

In both films, evil is an ever-present force. It is often tangible (as in The Road, in which the physical darkness is often associated with the presence of evil), and permeates both landscapes and individuals, bending them away from what is true toward what is rotten and dead.

What is striking in Lawless particularly is the director's reluctance to show evil directly, instead intimating its presence and horror through suggestion and the withholding of detail. Evil is certainly there, and it is certainly evil, but there's no reason to dwell on it directly because, as evil, it is inherently not worth our devoted attention. By contrast, the camera lingers long on the central characters who, though lawless themselves (they're Depression-era bootleggers in Franklin County, VA), are nonetheless devoted to an ethic and character standard that has no reason to hide itself.

The film featured exquisitely fine performances all round, but of special note are the roles of the three brothers Forrest, Howard, and Jack Bondurant, played by Tom Hardy, Jason Clarke, and Shia LaBeouf respectively. Each actor endows his character with a complexity, humanity and power that could never exist in a purely evil person....as brilliantly demonstrated by Guy Pearce's role as the bad guy, a chilling individual indeed, but more chilling because he lacks so much depth.

Hillcoat doesn't pander to our desire for titillation by showing us just how bad Pearce's character (Charlie Rakes) is, instead giving us hints that get the point across, while saving the camera's gaze mostly for depictions of the horrors evil causes, as well as the constant moral quandaries with which principled people are constantly confronted.

Lawless is a good film for a number of reasons; but it's especially refreshing to find a movie that gets at least one important thing very right. Societies and cultures are always huddling around in dark places, hoping the smoke never clears. A film like Hillcoat's latest effort looms bright, just like the bootleg stills on the hillsides of Franklin County.

Wednesday, September 19, 2012

The Tribulation of Temptation

It's easy to think of temptation in terms of its object. The point, we assume, is that we aren't supposed to have something we want. If a Porsche drives by, we identify the automobile itself as our temptation, that somehow it is the car itself that is tempting. This is completely wrong: the temptation isn't the car, but to engage in sinful thoughts about the car, i.e., envy and covetousness.

To be mistaken on this point leads to two problems. The first is to make us think that objects themselves are bad; the second, and worse, mistake is to think that temptation itself is somehow sin, that we incur guilt when we are tempted. If this latter point were true, Christ Himself would have been guilty of sin, because He was tempted by the Devil in the desert.

This temptation of Jesus is often presented with an underlying confusion. If Christ was, by His nature, not able to succumb to temptation, why did His temptation at the hands of Satan make Him exhausted to the point that angels had to administer to Him? This confusion, it seems to me, results from the objectification of temptation.

If Christ's exhaustion resulted from His desire for what the Devil offered, His sinless nature and perpetual sinless state would be called into question. As Christ Himself points out again and again, it isn't simply our actions that implicate us, but our thoughts and attitudes as well, anything that is in opposition to God's will and Law.

On the other hand, if we take temptation to be another form of tribulation or trial, a hardship we endure rather than a desire we repress, there is no confusion. Christ was so exhausted because His temptation came directly from the Devil himself. Things aren't bad in themselves: Christ in fact received all the things the Devil offered Him, but from God not Satan.

How much more able to withstand temptation will we be if we can learn to see it as tribulation rather than simply thwarted desire? It's not that the sin we want to commit is something that actually should be desired: the point is that we endure the temptation and conquer it through Jesus' power and grace because it should not be desired. Temptation is no sin, but we must resist it so that we do not sin.

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Rule Suburbia

My wife and I went camping about a week ago. We cooked all our food over a fire, slept on the implacably hard ground, felt the morning coolness, and walked to a small lake. It was a lovely weekend, but it was far from the escape I'd envisioned.

Americans (for the most part) don't understand the purpose of camping. The campground where we stayed was wooded and close to the beach....and resembled nothing so much as suburbia relocated to the outdoors.

Here was the opportunity to leave daily existence with its distractions and boredom behind, and instead these hundreds of campers decided to bring the distractions and boredom with them, to use while complaining about the mosquitoes and the dirt.

I'm not sure what that is, but it's not camping. No commitment to enjoying nature or a primitive existence here. Instead, RVs with televisions larger than my tent, smartphones constantly vomiting "personalized" ringtones shared by thousands of people, microwaved meals (again, courtesy of the RVs), screaming children, loud music, and generators powering TVs to which were attached Xboxes and Wiis.

Why even go camping?! Unless you embrace the experience, living out of doors, even temporarily, is miserable. You don't get to shower properly, you don't get a good night's sleep, your food is undercooked, and there's mud everywhere. All of which become genuine pleasures when you seek them as an alternative to the daily routine—and even more annoying and aggravating if you're trying to pursue your daily routine despite them.

The behavior I witnessed at the campground (ironically) is the result of certain strands of Christian thinking as much as typical American consumerism. The idea that God calls man to dominion over the created world has been so bent out of shape that many now take it to mean we have the right of all creation, that it belongs to us to do with as we will. This is neither a proper understanding of dominion, nor a proper understanding of the Church's role in relation to Jesus Christ.

But this idea has led in turn to a worse one: the idea that creation is in fact meant to serve us. While I don't for a second intend to imply that the opposite is true (we are not the servants of creation, either), or that we should worship nature or extend toward it more respect than God Himself has given it, I do mean to imply that man is still part of the created order, crown though he may be, and as such has no right to turn it to purposes beyond what God has designated for it.

As the great Jacques Ellul pointed out, cities were first formed as acts of rebellion against God. That's not to say Christians shouldn't live in cities; cities are as viable a dwelling for Christians as for anyone else, especially given that the New Jerusalem is itself a city. But cities, while they have their place, should not be allowed to encroach further than their own jurisdiction.

There are things nature tells us about ourselves and (more importantly) about God that we can never learn in an urban or metropolitan area. To take the city into nature, therefore, is to wilfully subject the wilderness to man's desire for comfort, his desire for control, even his desire for community that is not God-sanctioned. For how can God condone community that is predicated on mere numbers and presence, rather than on meaningful knowledge and relationships?

God is not nature, as the pantheists assert, nor is he present in nature the way panentheists suggest; but He is the Lord of nature just as he is the Lord of the city, the Lord of the Sabbath, the Lord of Heaven, and the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. The insensate drive to bring man's creation wherever man goes is not only arrogant, it's idolatrous.

I wouldn't imagine these ideas are conscious in most people, but I would suggest they are at least subconsciously present to one degree or another. I'm not going to stop camping as a result of this nonsense, though; but I am going to find a more secluded place to do it in.

Monday, September 17, 2012

Art's Objective Standards II

Once the creator's intent, and ability to consistently and effectively convey that intent, have been determined, it's essential to then assess the content of any work of art. Is what the creator is saying good? Does it make logical sense, and does it fit into what we know about the world, human nature, God, and history? Or is it humanistic, cliche, pernicious, false?

In our time, it's considered passe, uncharitable, and to some extent even dangerous to make value judgements of any kind. The typical postmodern bilge about "it may not be right for me, but it's right for you" or "one must find truth/peace/meaning in one's own way" have conditioned entire populations to refrain from judging anything on strictly moral grounds, instead reducing all art criticism to "I like it" or "I don't like it" or to mere intellectual posturing.

Even Christians have largely accepted these conditions. Instead of holding everything up to Scripture for comparison and analysis, we retreat into the fallible and usually inaccurate territory of trying to "feel" whether things are good or not. Unfortunately, our feelings are too susceptible to sin, illogic and confusion to ever be appropriate guides. This is why the Medievals insisted emotion must be subservient to the reason, and the reason to divine authority; without this graduated chain of command, we're left with the slavery of solipsistic subjectivity.

As a result, we have Christians who love the movie Braveheart, Christians who read the Twilight novels religiously, Christians who listen to Eminem on a regular basis, all because they've (consciously or unconsciously) jettisoned the idea that there's an ideal standard of good and bad by which to evaluate everything. I'm not arguing for monasticism; watch Braveheart, read Twilight, listen to Eminem: but do so from a judgemental standpoint, determining whether these things are the types of things Christians ought to fill their minds with on a regular basis.

This is the real crux of the issue: people on both sides try to force a dichotomy, and dichotomies are nearly always false. On the one hand are those who say we (as Christians) shouldn't engage the culture at all, that even the most minimal contact with secular art will pollute us beyond repair, and that there's nothing the world has to offer us on any level. On the other hand are those Christians who assume that interacting with art means we have to accept it all willy-nilly and immerse ourselves in it if we want to have any kind of voice.

The truth is less narrow and less broad than both of those. Christ never tells us to close our eyes, put our hands over our ears, shut our mouths, or tie our hands behind our backs. He tells us to be in the world, but not of it. In other words, live among people, but don't let them carry you away with false beliefs or sinful behavior. In a very real sense, this requires knowing something of the culture in order to combat it and offer something more real in response.

What is wrong is to accept anything with a meaningless, vapid or pernicious message as an integral part of our daily lives. I wouldn't now why Braveheart is a bad movie if I'd never watched it, but if I continued to watch it over and over again knowing it is bad, that's when I've crossed the line of reasonableness and godly character. Maybe many viewers don't know why it's bad, but that simply reflects lack of absorption in the one thing we ought to revisit every day as often as possible: God's Word.

It's frankly disturbing how many people say they haven't got time to read their Bible, but they spend hours (or even one hour) watching television or listening to music or reading comics every single day, seemingly unaware of the hypocrisy. There is only one sure standard by which to judge all things, and that is God's Word, and any Christian who attempts to "engage" the culture on any level without the protection of Scripture is doomed to failure or complete defeat.

Christians ought to understand the culture around them, and we all have a responsibility to respond in a biblical manner: what we should never do is replace our adherence to God's Word with this understanding. Ironically, it is such an exchange that makes any insight gained utterly meaningless, and which simultaneously undercuts any witness or responsible voice we might have. To understand art, we must understand the Bible, and we must understand it more thoroughly and more faithfully than any painting, novel, album, statue, or film.