Monday, August 13, 2012

no works were cited in the writing of this post

Among the many lies of modernism, that of intellectual property is particularly pernicious. No one owns thoughts; there are no wholly original ideas; and if truth is the object, what does it matter if a thinker is credited or not? For all the talk of humanism, intellectuals are seldom humanists when it comes to disseminating the concepts they claim will help humanity steady its course and become what it ought to become.

One of the foremost manifestations of this problem is the slavish commitment to constructing elaborate works cited pages in any scholarly work, whether in a book, a magazine article, or a journal essay. Any borrowed thought or fact is revealed as such, and proper tribute paid to the supposed originator. Aside from the fact that this makes reading (at least, reading conscientiously) much more of a chore, this deliberate self-scrutiny is destructive in other ways.

It assumes two things that aren't true: that there are original ideas, and that the originator of an idea has some claim or ownership of it, much like the holder of a patent. As for the first, there is nothing new under the sun. No idea or thought is born brand new in the mind of even the most brilliant thinker, but is instead the culmination of thought before him by which he is influenced. His idea may be a progression or elaboration of a previous idea, but it doesn't belong to him any more than the ozone layer belongs to Germany, or Jupiter belongs to Gambia.

The second idea is worse, however. To assume that each thinker is entitled to (if not monetary, at least) intellectual remuneration for his ideas is to make the development and proper attribution of thought more important than the thought itself. Obviously this has a monetary element (especially in our democratic capitalist society), but it also implies that individual men and women are more important than the larger human community they claim to serve.

Good philosophers, theologians, and scientists do their intellectual work, not for acclaim or honor, but to improve the condition of themselves and other people. Only those who wish for no more than acclaim will insist that they be properly cited wherever their ideas or propositions appear in the works of others.

I'm not saying proofs should be withheld when dubious or unpopular claims are made—showing that you aren't the only one proposing the Chinese beat Europe to the North American continent, for instance, is just good scholarship. But if all ideas are to be attributed properly, every sentence in every book would be cited. Instead, authors selectively cite, thus leaving ambiguous the very substantial and concrete fact that everything they commit to print has been espoused, proposed, or at least introduced by someone before them.

For ancient moderns, the originator of an idea matters far less than the idea itself. If one of my ideas is disseminated (however modified and improved it might be) without my knowledge and with no due recognition attributed to me, what should I care? Especially if the dissemination results in some positive response, why should I care whether I'm cited as the originator of the idea? If I engage in intellectual work for the right reasons, my only concern should be that people engage the ideas, and that their effect is good rather than pernicious or non-existent.

Friday, August 10, 2012

Divine Horror

Sinful man in the presence of God is a more terrifying prospect than any other, with the exception of eternal separation from Him. The immediacy and completeness of our undoing were we, unchanged, to enter Heaven's throne room is incomprehensible and truly awful.

This is divine terror.

Modern man has shined the light of reason in every corner and proclaimed all of them empty of anything but matter, and so his fears are redistributed, refined, in many ways eliminated. If God isn't lurking in the dark, what is there to fear? Sickness, after all, can be cured; crocodiles can't outswim motorboats; airplanes are still the safest way to travel.

These were never the true fears of man, however. Man has always been afraid (and rightly so) of divine judgement, divine retribution, divine displeasure. God hates evil, and all humans not covered by the blood of Christ are subject to His wrath, and there is no fear more legitimate or more complete than the fear of holy destruction at the hands of a wrathful God.

We tend to think of horror in terms of darkness and evil, as though the most terrifying thing we can encounter is anything opposed to or condemned by God. This is a lie we tell ourselves to avoid the truth. The most terrifying thing we can face is God Himself.

Even the redeemed ought to fear God. If He is the ruler of all things, the creator of all things, and the ultimate authority of the universe, can we really expect it to be otherwise? In the Bible, those who confront Him are reduced to babbling, prostration, or ashes. He is the wholly other, the ultimately distinct, the all-powerful, and sinful, small man does right to fear Him.

It isn't stories of demons that should scare God's people: the name of Christ is sufficient to protect us from Satan's minions. We should fear, rather, displeasing God, disobeying Him, incurring in any way the wrath that is rightfully His.

And we should spread this fear like a righteous and miraculous disease among all people. The fear of God is the beginning of wisdom, and we should desire all men to become wise. If we leave this out of our Gospel, we've left the true Gospel for a human one that robs God of His power, and ultimately incurs and deserves His wrath.

Thursday, August 9, 2012

The End of Knowledge

When I suggested what we see can play us false, I wasn't suggesting we shouldn't look.

God gave mankind rational faculties to be used, the powers of thought and observation in order to expand our minds and our understanding, imaginations to make inferences and to create and foster ideas. Knowledge is a good thing, and it is a God-sanctioned thing.

There are two essential kinds of knowledge: that obtained through study and observation, and that transmitted by God through Scripture. The former must be subordinated to the latter if we're to take the latter seriously to any extent. If the Bible is God's revelation to us, it is the highest and best knowledge we can have (and confessional Christians assert that this is in fact the case).

That doesn't mean knowledge external to the Bible is useless. As God has created all things, all things are worthy of our study. We study history, science, philosophy, art, mathematics, etc., in an effort to better understand people and the world around us; but as Christians, we study theology first, and compare everything else we learn to what we know about God. There is little value in studying anything but God Himself for its own sake, however; instead, we seek to understand in order to glorify and serve Him better.

If the Bible says one thing, why do we assume it means another? Or that "science" (as though it's an entity with independent intelligence and will) can show us where the written revelation of Almighty God is wrong or insufficient or naive? This is the worst kind of assumption, one that threatens the validity of any message we claim to preach from biblical precepts.

Human knowledge that is not subordinated to divine revelation and knowledge is simply rebellion. Of course, non-Christians are able to say true things, but their approach to study tarnishes their ability to study truthfully. God is truth; human knowledge not subjected to God is either untruth, partial truth, or anti-truth. We do not study merely to know (except in the case of God Himself), we study to serve and to obey and to love.

The Medieval thinkers understood this. For men like Thomas Aquinas, the end of knowledge is not knowledge, but love. And this love is not directionless and vague: it is the love of God Himself, who grants us knowledge by His own grace and power. Christians who eschew knowledge and study are faithless to the principles of Scripture; but so too are those who study merely to accrue knowledge for its own sake.

To ignore the world around us is to ignore what God has made, and that is rebellion of a different kind. Yet, all our looking is blindness if we aren't animated by love of the Creator and a desire to subject all things in our various spheres to Him and Him alone.

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Seeing isn't necessarily believing.

Things in Christianity are pretty black and white. Sin is evil; God is holy; Jesus Christ is the only way to the Father; history is teleological and Providentially ordered. Unfortunately, people have always liked blurring the straight lines until Christian thought is indistinguishable from its secular counterparts. One of the lines perpetually blurred (at least in the Modern and Postmodern eras) is the one between creation and evolution.

It's ironic that scientists who affirm the widespread spontaneity of evolutionary theory like to make fun of those Medieval persons who (presumably) thought creatures like mice and fleas spontaneously generated from piles of dirty clothes or refuse. What's not funny is that many Christians stumble over themselves to defend the faulty Medieval ideas, instead of pointing right back at Darwinism and evolutionism and laughing just as loudly.

It's also depressing when Christians try to impress their secular colleagues and friends by appearing open-minded and accepting both Christianity and evolutionary theory. I'm no real friend of a lot of "Creation science," but I'm also not a fan of syncretization or kowtowing to the supposed secular "authorities." What makes us think Modern man is a better authority on Earth origins than God Himself, who inspired the Genesis account as recorded by its ancient author? If we accept the Bible as God's Word, why do we insist on subordinating it to fallible human observation and theory?

The real reason evolution isn't compatible with Christianity, however, doesn't have anything to do with the fossil record or dinosaurs or the speed of light. Those are phenomena which, despite the loud protestations of Scientists, are open to interpretation. Evolution is inherently anti-Christian because it blurs and twists the straight lines of Scripture.

God created man in His image, with an immortal soul, distinct sexes, and a teleological purpose (the care of planet Earth and the service of Himself). None of this is possible if man emerged by slow degrees from lesser forms, or even from merely different forms—the soul, for instance, would have had to evolve rather than being made by express decree of the Father of all things.

More importantly, the sin nature of Adam imparted to all his children would be a philosophical and theological mistake if he wasn't the first of the species. In fact, there would be a whole slew of folks running around on the earth in complete moral and spiritual innocence (yet, astonishingly, killing animals and each other, and dying of old age) long before our "first father" was even a twinkle in his troglodyte father's eye. This is true even if you take the Eden story symbolically.

I don't profess to know all about science, the nature of physics, etc. Far from it, in fact. But I think we'd all be closer to the truth if we echoed Socrates' words that wisdom is the knowledge that we know nothing. In the book of Job, God declares that only He knows the truth behind the mysteries of nature, having made them Himself, and continuing Himself to control them. If God makes a declaration, who are we to controvert it? Our eyes deceive us, and they deceive our souls, and only God is able to rescue us from ignorance by the knowledge of His Word.

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

The Opposite of Happiness

Joy is not a door that we open or close at will. It isn't a burning in the bosom, a fire in the belly, or a pang in the chest. You don't unroll joy like a flag and pledge your allegiance, you can't manufacture it, and you can't trade it for anything.

If you've ever experienced it, you wouldn't want to trade it for anything. It's a fierceness that rends, a sublimity that transcends, and a fear mixed with wonder that eludes language. Joy is simply the true presence of God.

But it's not an emotion. Joy can induce emotion, to some extent joy must induce emotion, but it also induces and even results from rational thought. As God's presence, joy isn't definable in strict terms, as a chair is definable—it isn't one thing or another.

Why do we so often insist on limiting it to mere emotion? Emotions are changeable, they swing according to external influence, emotions well up in us or diminish. Paul wouldn't expect us to maintain constant joy if it was simply another emotion.

God's presence, however, he can command us to cultivate and maintain. We do this through external means, prayer, reading the Bible, singing hymns, fellowshipping with other believers, pursuing lives of holiness, eschewing sin. These are means of knowledge, primarily, not wells of emotion or feeling.

In the old days, happiness was simply a meetness of incident or coincidence. If two events coalesced to produce a positive outcome, it was a happy occasion. Now, however, happiness is anything that makes us feel good. So, people are always out to make themselves happy.

This new version of happiness is the opposite of joy. God isn't out to make us happy: He's out to make us humans willing to obey Him and glorify Him. He does this through our pursuit of joy, by which He guides us closer and nearer to Himself.

As J.I. Packer has noted, joy is possible even in the midst of spiritual struggle and doubt. This would be impossible were joy simply another emotion like anger or glee. But if joy is the presence of God, it is possible in the worst times and the best, in the midst of struggle and in the midst of ease.

Joy, then, is only attainable through knowledge of the One on whose presence it depends. How can we experience that which we do not know? The experience itself is knowledge, but the experience depends not on simple relationship, but on investigation. Why else would our source of knowledge about God be the Bible, a book of propositional statements, eternal truth, and knowledge?

Happiness isn't unique to Christians. Anyone can feel happy, because humans are feeling beings, and both Christians and non-Christians are humans. Only Christians, however, can experience true joy, the joy that comes from knowing God through the means he's given us. If we lose sight of this, we've lost our faith, and with it the saving knowledge only Christ can give.

Monday, August 6, 2012

No more false alarms.

I'm really back. Equilibrium of a sort has been achieved. Also, I love my wife.

True Love

The Cross is a symbol of relief, but only in the sense that it's first a symbol of judgement. A lot of people seem to think the sacrifice of Christ is simply carte blanche approval of the individual who acknowledges it, and a lot of these people teach this in Christ's name. They see lives as broken pitchers that need to be repaired and filled up with "love," not as dirty jars that need to be cleaned inside and out and filled with the Holy Spirit.

How this doctrine has managed to find its way into Christianity may be argued. I would suggest it's a combination of divorcing the "God of the Old Testament" from the Jesus Christ of the New (they're one and the same), and the Arminian and semi-Pelagian doctrines that have infiltrated the Church so thoroughly and so destructively. Be that as it may, the problem still stands, and even conservative Christians seem increasingly unwilling (or maybe simply unable) to confront it.

Christ crucified and resurrected is indeed our greatest hope, but it is also our greatest indictment. Our sin condemned Him, and our sin required so great a compensation. On the Cross, Jesus Christ suffered true hell: separation from God the Father and God the Holy Spirit. He became sin on our behalf and was wrenched from the Triune Godhead as punishment for evil he'd never committed, evil that we inherit and perpetrate as Sons of Adam.

Church people have been making a big noise lately about the need for Christians to "love" other people, as if those people won't become Christians unless those already in the fold are nice to them and don't judge them. This is trash doctrine of the worst kind. Of course I'm not advocating nastiness or boorishness; far from it. But if we simply wink at sin in an effort to "get people saved," we've actually helped condemn them to Hell, and possibly ourselves as well.

The Gospel is that we're stained with sin and need deliverance if we hope to gain entry into God's presence, holy and uncompromising as He is. The new gospel states that we're all just people in need of affection and earthly blessing in the form of warm hugs and happy times. Garbage and nonsense! We are bound to show each other our sin in order to illuminate our need for salvation through repentance. Anything less is not love of any kind, but hatred, a willingness to ignore the truth and deny those we seek to reach any of the real blessings true faith entails.

Maybe it's fear that brings this kind of thinking. More likely it's simply a lack of faith, a denial that the sacrifice of Christ is sufficient to save, or that we're not really in need of eternal rescue from the pit of Hell. Whatever it is, it's not true love. True love is truthful, true love condemns and judges in order to bring about repentance and reconciliation. God's presence isn't crowded with imperfection and sinful people: it's filled with people He's made perfect through His Son, brought alive through death, and purged finally of all shame before entering Heaven.

But what about the sinners and whores Jesus hung out with? some will say. Well, what about them? The case is clear: Jesus spent His time preaching to the lost, calling them not to continue in their old sins but to abandon their earthly lusts, repent, and follow Him. The call hasn't changed. If we accept the Cross as our savlation, we must also admit the unfathomable burden of our sin, the need to turn from it, and the necessity of Christ's true love to save us from lies, hypocrisy, and all the other sins that twist His Gospel into a humanist manifesto without power and ultimately without love.