Wednesday, April 3, 2013

the Word is the revelation (John 1:14-18)

Our only certain knowledge of God derives from the Christian Bible, both the Old and New Testaments in their entirety. And yet the Word of God is a term better applied to Jesus Christ than to the theopneustos (God-breathed) Scriptures. Certainly, what we know of Jesus is found in the Bible, but when the apostle John spoke of "the Word of God" he was speaking of God's self-revelation in the form of His only-begotten Son.

As humans very attached to our physicality, we like to have objects to tie our faith on. God has granted us two eminently physical elements in the sacraments of baptism and the Lord's Supper, but we are seldom satisfied with what we've been given. All of us are prone to searching beyond the stated means of grace for some kind of object in which to put our trust and on which to found our certainty. For many, that object is the Bible.

This is going to sound to some like I'm saying something I'm not. The Bible is central to our faith in that it was inspired by God and tells us everything He intended to directly reveal about Himself. We can have no real faith without the Bible. I affirm these and other statements like them. What I do not affirm is that it is the Bible in which we put our faith.

Evidential apologetics and other modernist attitudes implicitly take the view that the Bible is the source of our faith. Evidentialists work hard to prove that the Bible is trustworthy, that the events recorded in it actually happened, etc. Anti-intellectuals share this attitude, though with a slightly different trajectory: they fall back on "the Bible says so" response to any challenges to their beliefs and attitudes.

Christians put their faith in Jesus Christ. The Bible reveals to those who believe the nature, character, and doings of the triune God, but it isn't the source of faith, and its veracity doesn't depend on our ability to defend it or prove its truth. The Bible is a subservient revelation to the incarnation of Christ, Who is the truest revelation of God to mankind; we must hold to it as our only source and rule of doctrine and life, but we must receive our faith from Christ Himself, and He alone must be the object of our faith. All else is subsidiary.

Friday, March 29, 2013

I AM, therefore we are. (John 3:1-21)

Commentators have rendered Descartes's first principle cogito ergo sum ("I think, therefore I am"), though a more accurate rendering would be dubito ergo sum ("I doubt, therefore I am"). Philosophers are fond of making propositional statements anchored in their own limited range of perception, especially since the French novel-reading thinker first proposed doubt as the basis for knowledge.

Christians have an entirely different presupposition: I AM, therefore we are. We exist because it pleased God to create us. To put it more personally: I exist because I AM made me, and I have eternal life because I AM re-made me. Our existence is a fact, not because we can reason it out (solipsism), but because the great I AM creator God Yahweh declared it to be so.

Any other starting point is wrong. God is at the center of all things, and He has revealed Himself to us through His holy Scripture, in which He also describes our creation. There is no way to trust the validity or truth of Scripture unless we accept the whole truth of Scripture, and unless we accept it as God's self-revelation rather than the musings of fallible humans.

If the Bible is only a collection of fallible human writings, we are fools to put any faith or trust in it. Faith is an all-or-nothing venture, not a pick-and-choose affair. When we trust the Word of God as our ultimate source of wisdom (rather than our doubt, or knowledge, or philosophy, or whatever), we see that our existence is dependent on nothing else than God Himself, and that our spiritual life issues only from His grace and will.

Thursday, March 28, 2013

Causal Love (1 John 4:19)

"We love because He first loved us" (1 John 4:19).

This isn't merely reciprocal love, it's a causal fact. Reciprocity declares that God began loving us at some point, and therefore we respond in love. The biblical doctrine is much different: in Psalm 103:17-18, David says, "But the steadfast love of the Lord is from everlasting to everlasting on those who fear Him, and His righteousness to children's children, to those who keep His covenant and remember to do His commandments."

Of course that doesn't mean any of us keep His covenant or do His commandments—through our faith in Christ we receive the imputation of righteousness (Ephesians 2:8-10; Romans 3:21-31). But the fact that God's love is "from everlasting to everlasting" shows that He never (as the great Geerhardus Vos put it) began to love us. Rather, God always loved His elect children, before the foundation of the world (Ephesians 1:3-14).

If we bear this in mind, we won't fall into anti-Gospel attitudes that demand of us something we can't give. No one is able to conjure love for God out of his own deceitful, sin-poisoned heart, which is what a reciprocal view of 1 John 4:19 leads to. But if we understand God's love to be causal, i.e. that from which our love flows, we can embrace fully the glory of the Gospel message that God raises dead sinners to life.

How do we love God and keep His commandments, then? We trust in Christ for our salvation. Only the God-man Jesus was able to love God the Father as His righteousness, law, and majesty demand, but through the faith He gives us that perfect love is imputed to us. Salvation is about God: He bestows it, He maintains it (Hebrews 12:1-2), and He is glorified by it. Truly, we love Him because He loved us from everlasting to everlasting.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Real Community (Hebrews 10:24-25)

A big deal is made these days about "community." In many Christian circles, the idea of community actually has more to do with Eastern collectivist philosophy than the biblical doctrine of the Church. Leaders, particularly those within the purpose-driven and emergent strands of broader Christianity, have no real concern for individuals: their focus is the group, the city, the community.

The word community as such is foreign to Scripture. There is the covenant people of God, there are the nations, there are the enemies of Yahweh, but none of these are characterized as communities in the modern (or shall we say, postmodern) sense of the word. For contemporary postmodern leaders, "community" takes on political and sociological overtones, and the reason is clear—if the true doctrines of the individual forgiveness of sins and the particular salvation of souls are abandoned, Christianity becomes simply a program for social improvement and worldly betterment.

Thus, community becomes a political objective, while the Church becomes an outmoded concept. Sin is traded for talk of suffering; forgiveness ceases to be a gift of the sovereign God and becomes something we must bestow on ourselves or on rival communities; Jesus Christ is our leader, and therefore pastors aren't shepherds, they're CEOs.

The author of Hebrews has a different concept altogether. Hebrews 10:24-25 says, "And let us consider how to stir up one another to love and good works, not neglecting to meet together, as is the habit of some, but encouraging one another, and all the more as you see the Day drawing near." Inasmuch as the Church is called to community, it is for the purpose of encouragement in faith and good works, not to press some social agenda, to become yet another postmodern community in the midst of many.

At bottom, the call for community as defined by emergent leaders and their ilk is nothing more than a rejection of the uniqueness of the Church, the Christian faith, and (worst of all) Jesus Christ Himself. If sin is no longer something ubiquitous from which we need to be saved, then we're "free" to pursue a mere social agenda, side-by-side both physically and ideologically with heretics, pagans, and blasphemers. It's time we recovered the real community of the Church, and encourage one another to love and good works.

Monday, March 25, 2013

Being in Christ (Romans 8:1)

There are phrases used so commonly in the Word of God and quoted so often in church, seminary, and theology books that we lose their importance and depth. We've all heard and used the phrase "in Christ," but how often do we remind ourselves what that means?

It's not just a figure of speech. If it were simply a metaphor, then we'd be forced to admit we aren't literally "in Christ." But the apostle Paul constantly refers to our status "in Christ," making much of the statement doctrinally and practically.

All of the Bible is about Jesus Christ. If we read the book of Isaiah the prophet as the story, not of God's people, but as the story of God's people as lived out in the single God-man Jesus Christ, we get the key for understanding what it means to be in Christ.

Jesus Christ is the whole people of God distilled into a single person. He became sin on our behalf and in Himself; He defeated sin and death on our behalf and in Himself; He rose from the dead and ascended into heaven on our behalf and in Himself.

When we are saved by Him, we become part of His body, we are truly in Him. Everything that has been done for our salvation was done through Jesus Christ, the eternal God come to us in human flesh, and our only hope of salvation is to be found in Him.

We can't afford to think of the Gospel simply as the story of God's redemption of His people; we must think in terms of of God's redemption of His people through Jesus Christ. The Bible isn't about us, it's about our saviour, to whom alone belongs all glory and honor.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

The faithful 300.

I'm tired of writing about movies, books, and random stuff. There's nothing more important for Christians than to know their God through His Word, and the things of this world are distractions. I haven't become an ascetic, I've just come to the conclusion that if I'm going to take the time to blog, it better be about something eminently worthwhile. What's more worthwhile than God Himself?

As a result of this shift, I've renamed "St. George and the Dragons" to "The 300." I'm no fan of Zack Snyder, or of ancient Sparta; I am a fan of faithful men of God, including Gideon and his 300 faithful Israelites who defeated Midian under God's protection and in His power (Judges 7). I'd rather identify with the faithful people of God than with a legendary figure.

So, my blog is operational again, but it's not entirely the same blog. It's theological and apologetic, and my aim through it is to glorify our risen savior, Jesus Christ, whose self-revelation is more important than any script or novel or music album. If we don't know it better than we know ourselves, how can we call ourselves His children? This world offers no hope; Christ offers us the hope, not of peace or well-being here, but of the life of the world to come. Let us faithfully proclaim that hope.

Thursday, January 3, 2013

The Hobbit Part 1: An Expected Travesty

Having seen all of Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings films, I wasn't expecting anything from his version of The Hobbit. In some sense, I was expecting much less, simply because the story has less immediate depth and could therefore be easily twisted into something far different from its original form. What I witnessed in the film exceeded my expectations, as in, "This is far worse than I was even expecting it to be."

I feel embarrassed offering a spoiler alert, but here it is: I'm going to ruin the movie for anyone who hasn't seen it by explaining the last couple minutes and why they're awful.

In Tolkien's novel, Bilbo Baggins and Thorin Oakenshield have a strained relationship, due mostly to Thorin's regal bearing. He doubts Bilbo's ability to burgle, and Bilbo in turn is a bit put off by Thorin's majesterial presence. One of the most beautiful moments in the book comes at the end, when, after having endured all manner of adventures and terror together, Thorin repents of having mistreated Bilbo and even confers on him the honor of companionship.

Peter Jackson has obviously never had a meaningful relationship in his life, and obviously knows nothing of the nature of repentence, and is obviously just as uncultured and morally suspect as all Australians accuse all Kiwis of being.

At the end of the first installment of The Hobbit (the fact that a 300-page book is going to take up nine hours of screentime is an abomination in itself), the eagles have just dropped off Thorin's group atop the edge of the Misty Mountains. Bilbo hasn't been able to prove himself much at all yet, and one of his exploits in the book (orchestrating the rescue of the dwarves from the trolls) has even largely been stripped from him in the movie. So, there's little if any reason for Thorin to have had his mind changed as to Bilbo's worth.

And yet, he says something grumpy to Bilbo, followed by a big grin, and a "you're okay, kid" kind of speech, and topped off with a bear-hug. First of all, the nature of dwarves: not only are dwarves not teddy bears, but Thorin least of all would be bear-hugging anybody. He's a loner, and he's a king, and he's a grumpy old man.

Far more importantly, the grandeur and pathos of Thorin's deathbed repentence is completely obliterated by this premature and shallow reconciliation. It doesn't even make sense by the rules of good filmmaking: if you're going to stretch a story out through three long movies, you want to leave as much unresolved as possible in order to keep folks interested. Sadly, most people seem to be convinced The Hobbit movies are great before they've even seen them.

I wasn't expecting a good movie, but what I actually got was nearly unwatchable (and this from the guy who embarked on a ten-year quest for the worst movie ever made). If you have any love for Tolkien's work, at least watch this film with a critical eye. And don't tell me you were able to "just watch it as a movie, and not as the book," because Peter Jackson must be held to the standard of the book because his movie has the same title as the book, and because he's making money not on his own name but on the name of a great writer whom he's slandered and misrepresented.

Wednesday, January 2, 2013

I am boycotting all Regal Cinemas.

When my friend and I went to see Django Unchained in the theater last Monday, we had some idea the kind of movie we were paying to watch. We knew it would be typical Tarantino—violent and probably profanity-laden. But watching that film was our choice, and neither of us intended to watch it uncritically or thoughtlessly.

We did NOT pay to see NC-17 smut before the film even started. At the Salem Lancaster Mall Regal Cinema, the normal previews were followed by another with a mock warning that the preview was inappropriate for children but "perfect for you and your sick friends." What followed was a pornographic trailer for some "comedy" film that included "jokes" about rape, bestiality, etc. I stopped watching after the first few seconds, but I could hear everything.

I was so shaken up I couldn't concentrate on the film I'd come to see, so fifteen minutes into Django Unchained I found a manager and explained I wanted a refund for the two tickets, but still wanted to finish the movie I'd come to watch. After some haggling he obliged, but not before saying, "Well, you did come to see an R-rated movie."

To which I replied, "Yes, but I paid to see this R-rated movie, not some other one I don't know anything about, and certainly not an NC-17 one."

I'm no prude, and I've seen plenty of movies, many that would be considered edgy or even offensive, so it wasn't lack of exposure that made me hate this preview. It was obscene, callous, and perverted, but there was something worse: the "warning" before the trailer bore the Regal Cinemas logo and name. Not only were they wilfully showing filth, they were purposefully mocking and deriding anyone who would be offended by the content.

If it was just a trailer for a filthy movie, I'd have complained to my friend and left it at that. But the theater was making a calculated move to not only purvey smut, but to rub it in the faces of viewers while telling them they're idiots and morons if they find the content too twisted. If I choose to go to an R-rated film, I fully expect to see previews for R-rated movies, but I don't expect to see those movies themselves. And while I'll pay to watch No Country for Old Men or movies of its ilk, I wouldn't watch a filthy comedy whether I had to pay or not.

So, I'm never going to a Regal Cinema again. I don't usually boycott places, because I know that there is corruption and wickedness at all levels of every business, but this went too far and was enough to make me stand on principle. I won't try to convince anyone else to join me in this protest, but I have composed a letter to the Regal management, and if you intend to watch a movie at this or another Regal location, know what may be awaiting you and don't say I didn't warn you.

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Django Unchained

Quentin Tarantino has perfected the dubious art of crafting artistic and engrossing films that are still no more than schlock Z-movies. Pulp Fiction is undoubtedly his best work: it redefined the grammar of cinema in a way that most average movie-goers could still enjoy. Inglourious Basterds was also inriguing, mostly due to the fantastic performances of Til Schweiger, Brad Pitt, and the formerly brilliant Christoph Waltz. But none of these films are good in a moral or philosophical sense.

The world all these films inhabit is a dark parody of our own, nihilistic and cold. If good ever prevails it's an accident, and the only good that ever prevails can only be called good because it's slightly less bad (though never any less violent) than the evil over which it triumphs. Lately, Tarantino has been rewriting a parallel history to our own, recasting crucial moments into savage caricatures that turn sober events like World War II, the Civil War, and Southern racial slavery into excuses for graphic depictions of mindless violence.

Django Unchained is by far the worst of the lot so far. The plot is simple enough: a German bounty hunter (Christoph Waltz) teams up with the titular ex-slave (Jamie Foxx) to kill people for money; when they have enough money, they go on a wild, brutal revenge spree accompanied by gangsta rap tunes and glory shots. The blood comes in buckets, and there are unimaginably savage scenes which aren't meant to be indictments so much as catalysts for the audience's lust for "justice."

A couple of scenes in particular: a slave used for to-the-death bare knuckle fighting is eaten to death by dogs; one such fight is graphically depicted, complete with the winner finishing off his opponent with a hammer. Are these supposed to be exposes of the Old South? I'm about as far as you can get from being a Southern sympathizer, and I believe racial slavery to be one of the great evils of history, but these speactacles don't ring true. Instead, they incite the viewer against the perpetrators, keying them up for cheers and applause when the "hero" goes crazy and murders dozens of people.

This is wicked filmmaking. If anyone did half the things Django does on-screen in real life he'd be jailed, probably executed, and judged a sociopath. Why is it okay, then, to enjoy his antics through the medium of film? Why is it okay to glory in violence perpetrated in a fantasy reality, but not okay to be violent in real life? Simply put, it isn't, and the only justification to be made for such a film is that it feeds the darker appetites of humanity.

But don't we want to starve those appetites? As Christians who worship the Prince of Peace, we ought to eschew violence in all its forms, not hypocritically embrace fictional violence while decrying school shootings and rape. We ought to and we must as the citizens of Christ's kingdom and of the New Jerusalem.

Monday, December 17, 2012

Whom we ought to love.

My wife and I saw one of my favorite bands in concert last night—The Mountain Goats. John Darnielle is even better in person than on record. Two things struck me about the show.

First, common grace. God has preserved some good in the world, and it doesn't take a Christian to produce something beautiful or pleasing. Darnielle's spirituality is far from orthodox (in any sense), but his brilliant lyrics and music are worthy of admiration and enjoyment. Clearly, he gets some kind of pleasure in performance, and the audience shared it.

Second, the raggedy crowd. It struck me that the hipsters and freaks and weirdos were among those Christ came to save, but which His church so often has a special aversion toward. These are not mostly pretty people, people you'd feel safe around, or people you could talk small with. Yet they were all together in one place, united by a mote of common grace swirling in the dark.

What if they could all be united to us through Christ? What if we could grasp that grace common among us all and show them the particular grace of faith in Our Lord and eternal salvation? Why don't we? If we're willing to stand among them to watch a good show, why not stand before them with the Gospel? Why do we act as though common grace was any more than a taste of goodness in the midst of a crooked and depraved generation starving for the Bread of Life?

Monday, December 3, 2012

After long silence....

My wife is pregnant (just in her third trimester), I've been working 50+ hours per week for over a month now, there's always pleny of yard/housework to be done, and I've been teaching Sunday school every week at church. This isn't braggadocio, just an explanation of why there haven't been any posts for so long. Oh, my sister got married, I was in a dear friend's wedding, my car's been in and out of the mechanic's, and other stuff. So, I'm going to start writing shorter posts, but I'm going to commit to posting five days a week. Whether you've missed me or not, I'm back.

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

God is love.

There are infinite ways in which God is love. One of the most basic of these is that God is the only being of whom it can be said, His perfection not only justifies but demands His own self-love. If we long to approach His perfection through sanctification, the only path is to love God ourselves and submit to His will.

It doesn't bear simple intellectual acknowledgement: the idea that God's perfection necessitates His self-love requires sweet but arduous reflection. We finite human creatures are so far from perfection that our self-love is always tainted by impure motives, so much so that we are commanded in Scripture to not love ourselves. We are so imperfect that we are forbidden from loving ourselves, and yet God is so perfect that He must love Himself.

That He would also deign to save any of us is literally incomprehensible. We cannot take this seriously enough, yet in our arrogance and unpardonable silliness, we frequently (perhaps always, in one way or another) make light of God's love for us. We could try to excuse ourselves with an appeal to our imperfection, but that imperfection makes us no less culpable before the Sovereign of heaven, and yet He still shows us mercy and grace.

God is love. It sounds almost trite now, after millennia of misusing the phrase and shoving it into shapes in which it doesn't belong, after millennia of trying to make it trite. But it is the least trite statement with which we will ever be confronted. God is love means for His children that He pardons and forgives us, and for His enemies that He is quick to punish and mete justice.

How are these both true? Because of His self-love. If God loves Himself, then any people He has made His own He will also love, and any that have rejected Him without repentance He will force from His presence. Either of these are weighty enough concepts to incubate reflection throughout eternity, but it is the former that is most worthy of contemplation.

These three remain: faith, hope, and love, but the greatest of these is love. God is not some local deity or nebulous life essence to be greedy and mean (on the one hand) or silly and powerless (on the other). Love is great because God is love; and, likewise, God's love makes Him great. A king that is known only for his cruelty and oppression is soon forgotten or relegated to the big black book of history; but a King known for His magnanimity is never forgotten, though His enemies rightly fear the jealousy with which He guards His subjects.

It won't do to think improperly of God's love, but it also won't do to replace His love with intellectual propositions and hard sayings. The only path to enlightenment on this score is the Scripture and its revelations of God's character and nature. These bear constant reflection, not for the sake of mere knowledge, but in order to hear, feel, sense, experience and understand Yahweh, the God who is Love and who simply and absolutely and completely Is.

Thursday, October 11, 2012

NOT american literature you should read.

The King James Version of the Bible (for obvious reasons)

Paradise Lost, by John Milton (my favorite piece of literature)

The Pardoner's Tale, by Geoffrey Chaucer (my second favorite piece of literature)

The Seven Pillars of Wisdom, by T.E. Lawrence (maybe the finest example of an autobiography)

The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman, by Laurence Sterne (as Steve Coogan said, the first postmodern novel. one of the funniest books you'll ever read, and one of the best novels)

Essays, by George Orwell (the man was a genius and a prophet)

The Road to Serfdom, by Friedrich von Hayek (also a genius and prophet, and the spokesman for true conservatives in the traditional sense)

Pilgrim's Progress, by John Bunyan (you simply have to read this one)

A History of Philosophy Volumes 1-9, by Frederick Copleston S.J. (the best of its kind, and more entertaining than you might think)

Titus Andronicus, by William Shakespeare (Aaron the Moor)

The Lord of the Rings, by J.R.R. Tolkien (best fantasy, best Christian novel, best modern epic)

Njal's Saga, by anonymous (if you've never read an Icelandic saga, this is the best place to start; you won't find more violence or snappy one-liners in even the best Schwarzenegger movie)

The Scarlet and the Black, by Stendahl (my uncle thought this was the best novel ever written; I wouldn't go that far, but it's up there)

Fear and Trembling, by Soren Kierkegaard (the greatest Christian philosopher writes on the things that matter most)

Twilight of the Idols & The Anti-Christ, by Friedrich Nietzsche (the greatest Pagan philosopher writes on the things that matter most)

The Institutes of the Christian Religion, by John Calvin (theology as it was always meant to be--apprehendable yet deep, intellectual yet applicable and spiritual)

The First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women, by John Knox (first of all, the man knew how to title a book; second, the monstrous regiment was comprised of Elizabeth I, and his arguments are compelling)

If on a winter's night a traveler...., by Italo Calvino (so brilliant it's hard to understand why anyone since him has tried writing fiction, or whatever you call it)

The Master of the Day of Judgement, by Leo Perutz (a supernatural mystery story that actually makes sense and is actually scary)

Barnaby Rudge, by Charles Dickens (underrated and largely unread, this is a masterpiece in every sense)

Our Mutual Friend, by Charles Dickens (if Dickens had written nothing else, he'd still be the greatest novelist of all time)

The Death of Death in the Death of Christ, by John Owen (the Puritans are my heroes; this book is pure devotion to Jesus Christ)

The 13 1/2 Lives of Captain Bluebear, by Walter Moers (who knew Germans had such a sense of humor??)

Hunger, by Knut Hamsun (never has deprivation been so carefully rendered)

A Universal History of Infamy, by Jorge Luis Borges (why isn't this required reading everywhere?)

The Gormenghast Trilogy, by Mervyn Peake (post-World War II Europe in a fantasy setting; this novel will blow your mind and remind you that fiction can indeed be great and worthwhile)

The Tain, by anonymous (an Irish cattle raid in the roughest poetic language you'll ever encounter)

The Kalevala, by Elias Lonnrot (when Vainamoinen sings the world into existence, if you don't lose your breath you're heartless and inhuman)

Mr. Standfast, by John Buchan (spies who use codenames from Pilgrim's Progress AND a veteran of the Boer War who ends up in a fighter plane)

The City of God, by St. Augustine (duh)

and finally

The Complete Sherlock Holmes, by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (because really, he accomplished something great there)

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

American literature you should read.

The last post was fairly abstruse, so I compiled this list:

Moby-Dick, by Herman Melville (the Great American Novel, and the first experimental novel)

To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee (great first-hand introduction to the problem of American racism)

Babbitt, by Sinclair Lewis (best introduction to the "American dream" and business politics)
 
The Road, by Cormac McCarthy (just beautiful)
 
Walden, by Henry David Thoreau (explains why the 1960s happened)
 
The Grapes of Wrath, by John Steinbeck (one of the finest novels of all time, and best fictional presentation of the Depression)

The Old Man and the Sea, by Ernest Hemingway (fishing, baseball: it's the ultimate American adventure story)
 
Cat's Cradle, by Kurt Vonnegut (hilarious, one of the first great postmodern novels and a brilliant deconstruction of American civil religion and military smugness)

The Deerslayer, by James Fenimore Cooper (the first American adventure novel; at least, the first good one)
 
Wieland, by Charles Brockden Brown (the first American novel, and a great horror story)
 
Wise Blood, by Flannery O'Connor (a Southern Gothic allegory about Jesus and scary fundamentalists)
 
The Movie-Goer, by Walker Percy (an expose of American individualism and confusion)

The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym, by Edgar Allan Poe (a little-known but AWESOME horror/adventure story)
 
Black Boy, by Richard Wright (posing as an individual's autobiography, this is better described as the autobiography of blacks in America)
 
Roughing It, by Mark Twain (the American West as it really was)

Ethan Fromme, by Edith Wharton (heartbreaking, and very New England)
 
The Sea Wolf, by Jack London (survival of the fittest, more action-packed and scary than Call of the Wild)
 
As I Lay Dying, by William Faulkner (a dead woman tells of her life from the coffin her people are carrying her to her grave in)
 
The Bridge of San Luis Rey, by Thornton Wilder (great redemptive adventure story)
 
Hiroshima, by John Hersey (what America did to Japan in WWII, very sad)
 
Invisible Man, by Ralph Ellison (the Black experience told with full literary abandon)
 
The Thin Red Line, by James Jones (redemption in Guadalcanal; the best WWII novel ever)

On the Road, by Jack Kerouac (the American rebel spirit encapsulated in vigorous prose)
 
In Cold Blood, by Truman Capote (how real-life becomes fiction, in the form of a terrifying crime story)

Lie Down in Darkness, by William Styron (the finest stream of consciousness novel written by an American)
 
Starship Troopers, by Robert Heinlein (the great sci-fi novel by a man who knew sci-fi was more than just escapism)

Bless Me, Ultima, by Rudolfo Anaya (the best book no one's ever read, and the best Latino novel)
 
The Man in the High Tower, by Philip K. Dick (what if Hitler had won?)
 
The Lathe of Heaven, by Ursula K. LeGuin (what if Hitler hadn't won?)
 
Dune, by Frank Herbert (the greatest sci-fi novel of all time)

A Canticle for Leibowitz, by Walter M. Miller, Jr. (post-apocalyptic monks saving what remains of civilization while philosophizing: how awesome is that?)

Johnny Got His Gun, by Dalton Trumbo (the saddest war novel I've ever read, and one of the best)

The Things They Carried, by Tim O'Brien (man oh man oh man. maybe my favorite novel ever)

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

Ancient Modern Epistemology (Part I)

Ancient modernism is predicated on two assertions: That there is an external world which can be known directly, and that there is a spiritual reality which can be known only by the mediation of divine revelation. The first assertion is in turn based on two premises: That we, by experience, are able to apprehend and comprehend the physical realities to which we all are subject; and, that divine revelation tells us God created matter intentionally and placed man within it, to interact with and to exert influence over.

Some will protest that this is circular reasoning. How can the first assertion include an essential element of the second assertion without begging the question? The fact is, every philosophical position that is logically and practically cohesive is similarly interrelated. If the two foundational assertions were wholly independent, how could the structure stand? It would collapse like a building built on two foundations and insufficiently joined.

It is actually the second assertion that is primary. Left by himself, man can only produce absurd stories as to his origins, his telos, and his nature. Dropped as if by chance into the cosmos (as he perceives it), man is able only to postulate answers to his deepest questions based on chance, going so far in some cases as to declare the universe and everything in it without meaning, as though human civilization and the world of external realities exist simply because they exist, and that everything we suppose has inherent meaning is no more than a construct.

The only rational proposition is that something outside man produced him, along with everything else that exists. Did this origin point in turn have an origin? To suppose so is irrational: an infinite regression of origin points is as meaningless as a single cosmic chance. A number of mediatory points between the "original originator" and the world as we know it is similarly absurd, mainly because it's an unneccessary postulation, and secondarily because a force powerful enough to originate the cosmos wouldn't need intermediaries to accomplish the work.

Is this overly simplistic? Only if one's presuppositions have led one to the conclusion that there is no all-powerful God who controls all things in infinite wisdom and power. Complexity of the philosophical kind is only really requisite once the obvious and simple solutions have been relegated to the realm of impossibility. But in that case, any potential for philosophical freedom or exploration is also abolished: to limit possible explanations to the synthetic and complex is to abandon the philosophical project before it's even begun by setting for it arbitrary and inviolable boundaries.

Ironically, these are exactly the parameters set by those most vocal about the necessity of free thought, those whose idea of intellectual integrity is defined by the ability to think entirely outside structures, even as they limit themselves to the most tyrannical of philosophical frameworks. Ancient modern thinkers, on the other hand, allow for true intellectual liberty by asserting the knowableness of the cosmos and its God, by asserting the finitude of man's ability to comprehend, and by asserting the latitude within those two parameters for developing unique and creative ideas.

The pillar of ancient modern epistemology, then, is the understanding that man is not the originator of knowledge or truth but its discoverer by the grace of God. If we believe this, we necessarily believe that the world of external realities is knowable, that it is created by God, and that God Himself has spoken to us indirectly through this creation and directly through His Word.

Without such a foundation, the pursuit of knowledge or wisdom is fruitless, without ultimate meaning (or at least, without discernible ultimate meaning) and therefore mere nihilism. Ancient modernism rejects both this nihilism and its underlying materialism for a world of material and spiritual truth predicated on the creative purposes of the God of the Universe.

Monday, October 8, 2012

Ancient modernism is not a theory of everything.

First of all, the attempt to construct a theory of everything betrays a misunderstanding of both science and philosophy, and of their intersection. A theory of science has its place within the philosophical framework of ancient modernism, but theories are for science and philosophy is not science in the way that word is currently used.

What is a theory of everything? Marxism is probably the readiest and most accessible example. Karl Marx sought to explain every facet of existence under the rubric of economic evolution, interpreting history, religion, morality, war, and so on as part of a massive teleological project to bring all humanity out of subjugation via violent revolution.

That's an unfairly simplistic analysis of Marxism, to be sure, but it demonstrates the "theory of everything" principle: man's need to put everything into place and give it meaning in light of some "big picture" context. Even nihilists have a meaningful theory of everything (the idea that nothing has meaning is, in itself, an assertion of meaning).

Postmodernism would seem for many to have eliminated the need for or possibility of a theory of everything. More thoroughly even than nihilism, postmodernism destroys any basis for assertions of meaning, compelling its adherents to reject truth claims of every kind and defy meaning on even the most ontological level by accepting all truth as truth (and thereby, accepting none of it).

Yet, because human nature refuses to die, even in the face of existentialist assertions of its non-existence, even postmodernists infuse their philosophy with a strong dose of teleology. Maybe there isn't an all-encompassing end toward which mankind is headed, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't work hard to be accepting of one another in the interest of a loving and compassionate society.

I'm speaking, of course, primarily of postmodern popularizers. There are those under the label (though increasingly the label is becoming passe and old-fashioned) that would assert the supreme autonomy of every individual to construct a life for himself of his own imagining and desire. But this, too, is teleological, and amounts to a theory of everything.

A theory of everything only works in a world where there is no reliable truth, no ontological realities to affirm, no God and therefore no revelation. The man who accepts God's Word as his standard for truth and reality need not construct a comprehensive theory of everything beyond what the Bible offers—he need only understand what God says and live according to His precepts.

Ancient modernism is not an attempt to explain everything. It's a philosophical attitude which admits both intellectual curiosity and exploration, and reliance on God's self-revelation. It attempts to marry the naivete of the ancients and Medievals with the cynicism of the moderns, to bring skepticism under the directional guidance of Christian reason.

The goal of ancient modernism is neither to explain everything (except as the Bible allows), nor to foster credulity. We must be careful thinkers, but we must also affirm there are many things we will never and can never know, to be simultaneously bold and humble as people and as thinkers. One man can never come to truth alone, and it is the project of ancient modernism to overturn the rampant island-making that has characterized so much of modern, postmodern, and post-postmodern thought.

Friday, October 5, 2012

On Posturing

It would take a peculiarly unobservant person, or someone living in a dangerously insular society, not to notice the posturing that goes on all around us. Skinny kids in coffee shops carry huge books and name-drop obscure bands; dudes with shaved heads drive gigantic pickups and spit tobacco; the Amish wear clothes without zippers and look askance at "the English"; middle and upper middle class Americans buy boats and big houses and trips to Europe and SUVs.

Behind all this posturing are much less impressive realities: the obscure hipster bands are obscure because they're so bad no one wants to listen to them, and the books go unread because Dave Eggers and David Mitchell are boring; the pickup-driving rednecks are henpecked at home and hate their jobs; the Amish teach false doctrine and their communities often foster abuse; and the spendthrift American families are all deeply in debt.

So why posture? Do people really think no one can see past the facade? Are the posturers themselves unable to see past their own facade? or the facades of others? And yet one thing that typically characterizes those who posture is their finely cultivated ability to look past the surface of other peoples' lives to the more shallow interior: punks ridicule rednecks, rednecks ridicule yuppies, yuppies ridicule hipsters, hipsters ridicule normal people, and normal people ridicule punks.

Part of the problem is our innate willingness to stereotype. We see it as inevitable, so we give in on a regular basis and sort every person we see into a prepared category. This propensity is so deep seated we even stereotype ourselves, wearing the appropriate clothes, watching the appropriate TV shows, doing the appropriate things to fit into our chosen subculture or group. The act of stereotyping is precisely the act that allows us to see through facades even while maintaining our own.

What's really important isn't the stereotyping, however; it's the corresponding idea that the stereotype to which we belong is the only legitimate one. This is why we posture: to make sure everyone else sees to which group we belong, and that they understand our group is more important, more real, more authentic than theirs. And everyone does posture to one degree or another; some are less obvious, but we all seek identity in a group of some kind.

For Christians, this is sin. Not that we can't be scholars or mountain bikers or blues musicians: but we must not seek identity anywhere but in Christ and as members of His Church. Posturing is ultimately an act of idolatry, assuming that your chosen group is somehow superior to all the others, and that collectively you share an edge on reality. We must abandon posturing, and to the extent that it facilitates posturing we must abandon stereotyping.

Probably the worst form of posturing is that which goes on among Christians as Christians. We carry our Bible ostentatiously wherever we go, we drop catchphrases, we look askance at bums and the morally suspect, we put bumper stickers all over our cars, we wear fish and crosses on our T-shirts and jewelry. Where does this get us? If it's an attempt at evangelism, it fails because it's non-direct and amounts to no more than a show of piety; if it's anything else, it makes no sense.

Our only identity as Christians is as fallen humans saved by the grace of God and the Blood of Jesus and the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. We aren't cool, we aren't macho, we aren't sexy; we're nothing but broken and yet redeemed. The whole human race is broken—attempts to find wholeness as part of a group shouldn't surprise us, but neither should they seduce us. Only one group offers the wholeness we seek, and that is Christ's Body, and we should offer it to everyone humbly and without a hint of posturing or merely human identity-mongering.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Corruption vs. Glory

I watched one of my favorite movies the other day—El Cid (1961), the story of Spain's Medieval hero and defender against Muslim invasion from North Africa. One thing in particular stood out this time, something I hadn't noticed before, and that was the sharp distinction in the film's depiction of the militant Islamic forces and the Christian armies.

When the forces of Ben Yussuf are arrayed outside Valencia, we're given long shots of both the Islamic soldiers and their siege towers. The soldiers wear mostly black, carry strange shields of zebra skins and weird symbols, and march to the ominous sound of huge drums. Their siege towers are decorated with horned animal skulls, their spears are adorned with black feathers, and their are thousands upon thousands of them. They carry black flags.

The Christian knights ride white horses. They are dressed in white and red and gold, they carry dozens of brightly colored pennants and banners, their shields are gold and red. The Cid himself is the brightest of all, mounted on a white horse, wearing white and blue and silver, the sun breaking on his silver shield in every direction. Before they go into battle, they pray and are blessed by a priest.

Obviously, viewers are supposed to understand that Ben Yussuf's armies are the bad guys, and that the forces of El Cid and King Alfonso are good. We're also supposed to get a sense of Medieval morality, that there isn't a blurred no man's land between what is right and what is evil, but rather a sharp distinction and clear sides.

If that was all, El Cid would simply end up being another action movie, an adventure film set in the Middle Ages but that could be easily transposed onto any time period. I think the real message of the representation of the two armies goes much deeper, and that it shows not simply the difference between good and evil, but the nature of pagan warfare vs. Christian warfare.

Ben Yussuf's heathen armies attempt to strike fear in their enemies using that which they fear most: Death. They dress in black, they wave frightening shields, they mount skulls everywhere. They fear death because they have no real hope of salvation when it comes, and they expect their enemies to share this same fear.

The Christian armies, on the other hand, fear God, and therefore they awe their enemies, not with depictions and displays of death, but with portrayals of glory. Christians have nothing to fear in death, for it is our final sanctification. We fear God, the King of Creation, and we attempt to spread that fear wherever we go, not merely to terrify, but to reveal and to convert.

In history, El Cid Rodrigo de Bivar was a Christian knight dedicated to purity, chastity, loyalty, and piety, the only true foundations for any true gallantry and honor. The only way a man can live by these things is to fear God, not death, and yet to live as though death might overtake him at any moment. Anthony Mann's beautiful film ably depicts this, and for that we can be glad.

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

simplicity and depth

In his introduction to Athanasius' On the Incarnation, C.S. Lewis encourages readers to read at least one old book for every three modern ones. This is good advice, both because (as Lewis points out) the old books are so accessible, and because modern books tend to be infinitely more complex and specialized than they have any need or right to be.

This is particularly true of Christian books (precisely the kinds of books Lewis is talking about, actually). As he says in the introduction, a Christian book must stand the test of time before it can be widely accepted, not because years equal truth, but because Christians must hold it against the Bible and the rest of accepted orthodox Christian doctrine.

One of the most important reasons to read old books in the Christian tradition, however, is that they are much clearer than most of the books published in the last two hundred years. The farther back we go, the clearer the writing: the Apostles' and Nicene Creeds are models of clarity and brevity, as well as some of the oldest Christian documents we have.

It's not just that the writing is clearer, but that the ideas expressed are so much simpler and Gospel-oriented. Modern writers fall over themselves responding to critics, clarifying their highly specialized use of language, cutting away the baggage of centuries of scholarship, or simply adding to it with their own assertions and ideas.

Of course, there's nonsense among the older works, too. Not everything the Church Fathers wrote is worthwhile, there's plenty of bad Medieval theology, the Renaissance and Enlightenment were largely too man-centered, and so on. But you're also far more likely to find excellent Christian writing in the literature of these periods than in our own era.

I would argue that it wasn't primarily because those writers were smarter, or better stylists, or anything temporal like that: they were simply more in love with Christ's true Gospel and its application to the life and thought of every believer. The Puritans in particular (here I'm betraying my own bias) are able to balance incredibly deep theological reflections and baldly practical applications of that knowledge.

We often somehow think that the more complex something is, the deeper it is; John Calvin and Martin Luther ably disprove this as a matter of course in their writings. Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion is one of the deepest doctrinal works you'll ever encounter, but on every page he shows how the concepts he explores are important for our life in Christ. The same goes for Luther's The Bondage of the Will and John Owen's The Death of Death in the Death of Christ.

Theological scholarship is important: it would be disingenuous of me to suggest otherwise. At the same time, it must always be balanced by serious reflection on the core doctrines of our faith: Christ's work, death, and resurrection; God's sovereignty; the universal curse of sin and death under Adam; the justification and sanctification of the saints through Christ; the life everlasting. Without an unbreakable anchor in these truths, the scholarship is meaningless and even harmful.

Even (especially?) popular works aren't free from the trend I've identified. While they aren't scholarly, authors of these books find anything to talk about but the Gospel, appealing to socio-economic analysis, social gospel concerns, psychology, postmodern ideas of "story," etc. to connect their message to a modern audience. The truths a modern audience needs to understand and affirm, however, are the same as they were 2000 years ago, and so is human nature.

We could read all the modern books, mindful to cut through the dross, looking for the kernel of truth or insight in each one; or we can read the old books, the ones focused on Christ alone, and be genuinely enriched and quickened to better service. The message hasn't changed, after all; we've simply invented more ways of getting around its incisive and convicting truth.

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Ecclesiological Deism

The particular doctrinal mindset that allows Jack Crabtree to make his outrageous but not original claims is something I would call ecclesiological deism. It's a view I think he shares (to his chagrin, if he knew it) with many groups in contemporary Christendom. Basically, ecclesiological deism is the idea (implicit or explicit; both forms exist) that after Jesus instituted the Church, God stepped back and let His people sort things out for themselves.

Probably the most common source of this view is a misunderstanding of the apostolic age. If you think the Holy Spirit supply was simply cut off after the death of the last apostle, thus introducing an era of practical materialism, ED would make sense. Also, if our salvation depends primarily on knowledge, then it would make sense that we'd be fully responsible to apprehend it on our own through the exercise of our intellect and reason.

What any view leading to ED fails to acknowledge, however, is that the Church doesn't belong to Christians, but to Jesus Christ through the agency of the Holy Spirit for the Father's good pleasure and glory. The Church is not primarily a physical entity (though it has a physical element or manifestation), but a spiritual one. How else could Paul speak of it as the Body of Christ, the Bride of Christ, or the Temple of the Holy Spirit?

The implication for Jack's case is clear: if the Church is simply an invisible collective of people each striving for truth on their own recognizance, then of course he can reach the proper view of doctrine all by himself. If, however, the Church is the Body of Christ as maintained throughout the centuries by the Holy Spirit, his claims become a lot less plausible.

This isn't to say that no bad doctrine will ever creep into the Church. Because while the Holy Spirit is our guide and helper, we're also sinful human beings who don't always use our reason to the glory of God. It is to say that 2000 years of Christians haven't gotten the Gospel wrong. This isn't an intellectual cop-out: unless we think Christ abandoned His people to their own devices at the ascension, we have to understand that He left us with provisions against the complete loss of biblical truth in the form of His Spirit.

Perhaps Jack's ecclesiological deism results from his abandonment of the Trinity. People like Brian McLaren who hold similar (if not identical) beliefs seem to be influneced more by semi-Pelagian ideals and an overemphasis of common grace (both of which Jack seems to embrace as well). The temptation to elevate human beings beyond their due is a perennial problem, both within the Church and outside it. All we can do is renew our efforts to preserve the truth passed down to us from our spiritual forebears under the auspices of God's Holy Spirit.